Columns

Al Cardenas' Push for High-Speed Rail Soils His Conservative Credentials

By: Tom Tillison | Posted: February 10, 2011 12:55 PM
Tom Tillison -- use this version with columnsTom Tillison, Central Florida Tea Party Council, editor of Florida Political Press

*Corrected 2/11/11 2:30PM
As Kevin Derby reported for Sunshine State News, Al Cardenas, a former chairman of the Republican Party of Florida, was named Wednesday to head up the American Conservative Union (ACU), succeeding conservative icon David Keene who led the group for more than 25 years.

Cardenas, who had served as the ACU’s treasurer, was elected as chairman without opposition, despite grumblings from some social conservatives who maintained he did not share their commitment to traditional values.

“The American Conservative Union has a long and proud tradition of espousing and promoting the conservative goals of limited government and fiscal responsibility, and it’s my honor to do all I can to help further these worthy objectives,” said Cardenas.

High-speed rail opponents here in Florida may recognize Cardenas’ name. His firm represents one of the consortiums angling to bid for the high-speed rail contract, and he does lobbying work for Associated Industries of Florida, whose president chairs the recently formed High-Speed Rail Coalition.

Which begs the question, can the chairman of ACU, an organization that promotes "limited government and fiscal responsibility,"  also head an effort to promote high-speed rail using federal dollars at the same time? Is there a conflict of interest going on here?

Amid the grumblings that Cardenas is not "committed to conservative values" is his willingness to spend money that this nation does not have, which only adds to the national debt, further solidifying those concerns?

Republican Congresswoman Sandy Adams of District 24 referred to the rail initiative as “a misguided attempt to expand the reach of the federal government and spend limited taxpayer dollars on projects that our nation cannot afford.”

Cardenas takes over just in time for the Conservative Political Action Conference (CPAC), which begins Thursday in Washington, D.C.  No word yet if there will be a high-speed rail promotion in the lobby.

--

Tom Tillison is a member of the Central Florida Tea Party Council and edits the Florida Political Press from Orlando.

*An earlier version of the guest column, "Al Cardenas' Push for High-Speed Rail Soils His Conservative Credentials," contained an error. The error has been corrected in the column shown here. To clarify, Barney Bishop, president of Associated Industries of Florida, chairs the High-Speed Rail Coalition.


Comments (7)

Jane Hoffman
10:52PM FEB 12TH 2011
Mr. Tillison was a GOP operative last year who openly supported all of the pro-trail RINO candidates running for office; Cannon; Adams; Precourt; Horner; Webster - the whole lot.
More of the same - do one thing - talk out both sides of your mouth. No credibility at all, Mr. Tillison has never done anything successful in politics or public policy except talk.

Go forth and accomplish something then maybe folks will listen. Furthermore, don't support pro-rail RINOs and then criticize the rail boondoggles. One cannot serve two masters.
Tetsuo Langue
3:29PM FEB 10TH 2011
How in the world is supporting high speed rail not conservative? Would you rather have more freeways, which cost more? Do you want to increase the cost of business and people sit stuck in traffic and have to drive more and more miles through horrible suburban sprawl? I don't like excess government spending either, but HSR is an investment that pays off handsomely across the private sector, just like the original highway system did.
ccloo
8:53PM FEB 10TH 2011
HSR costs the taxpayers plenty. For example, for TriRail the taxpayer subsidizes $200 for every $2 ticket sold. HSR only works if you have densely populated areas near a station & then goes to a densely populated area. Orlando / Tampa does not fit the mold for what makes a HSR work. Just as in Washington DC where I lived, if you lived in the suburbs, you had to drive to a station and fight for a parking spot. Most people the didn't live within walking distance of a station.
HSR works in Europe b/c they have condensed populations.
So if you live in Orlando and you take the rail to Tampa, how are you going to get where you need to go since the area is so sprawling? Take a taxi? This becomes cost ineffective. And the same applies vice versa. How will you get to a station? How will you get to your destination once you get off the rail?
TomT
7:36PM FEB 10TH 2011
"HSR is an investment that pays off handsomely" - Seriously? There is not a system in the world that pays for itself without some type of government subsidy. And, is it conservative to continue adding billions of dollars to an out of control national debt? Is it conservative to continue placing tax burdens on the residents of the state? Yes, in the beginning there will be no tax obligation if they bring in private money, but at some point, it will fall back on the taxpayers of this state.

As for Cardenas, perhaps I should have mentioned that endorsed Charlie Crist for Governor...that just about disqualifies ANYONE from claiming a conservative label!
Just the Facts
11:42PM FEB 12TH 2011
It is interesting that people say anything these days without verifying the facts. The Northeast Corrdor of Amtrak covers its annual operating costs. Further, the Central Japan Railway system in Japan not only covers the operating cost, but also capital cost of the system and generates an annual profit for the shareholders of the private company. The bottom line is private companies are ready to deliver a private developed and run system to the State of Florida. It is about jobs and the future of Florida. Are you open to that or simply want to say no to progress?
Anthony
12:55PM FEB 11TH 2011
He supported Crist before Crist moved to more centrist values. When Crist changed his agenda for a 2010 senate nod, Cardenas dropped Crist and endorsed Rubio- and we know how that story ends. A seemingly unanimous appointment to chairman of ACU except the writer in Florida that disagrees... I JUST DON'T KNOW WHICH SIDE TO TAKE!
Mike S
12:09PM FEB 11TH 2011
One way to test for silliness in comments about rail (or any other transit) projects is to replace "train" or "bus" with "road" or "bridge" or "sidewalk" as in "There is not a sidewalk in the world that pays for itself without some kind of government subsidy." Right; so what's your point? Conservatives expect government to do those things that only government can do and provision of transportation infrastructure is one of them. There is no inherent conflict between being a conservative and supporting good tax-supported infrastructure, especially the kind that facilitates economic growth and opportunity