Billion-Dollar Florida Transit Plan Promises Light Rail, but Greenlights Buses

By: William Patrick FloridaWatchdog.org | Posted: January 27, 2014 3:55 AM
Bus in Pinellas County

Pinellas County‘s 900,000 residents have the opportunity of a generation: for a simple “yes” vote they could be next-in-line in Florida to receive a modern light rail transit system.

Voters would also be signing up for a $100 million annual sales tax increase to deliver the 24-mile light rail connecting downtown St. Petersburg to downtown Clearwater. The tax would take effect Jan. 1, 2016.

But for at least the next decade -- possibly 15 years -- while the light rail is slated for construction, residents would have to settle for buses. Lots of buses.

It’s all part of an ambitious public transit proposal called the Pinellas Greenlight Plan, which includes a 65 percent permanent expansion of the Pinellas Suncoast Transit Authority‘s bus system.

The majority of Pinellas County residents do not regularly use the PSTA’s 195 buses, but that doesn’t mean they won’t pay.

The planned expansion would cost taxpayers $147.8 million in capital costs, plus $150 million for the buses and another $45 million for a new bus hub, according to PSTA’s cost estimates.

The theory, according to Bob Lasher, PSTA’s external affairs officer, is that if they build it, people will come aboard.

“If you can get decent frequency on routes, ridership goes up,” Lasher told Watchdog.org.

Lasher said expanded funding through a property tax increase already allowed the transit authority to drop wait times along U.S. Highway 19, the county’s major north-south corridor, from 30 minutes to 20 minutes. The result, he said, was a 50 percent increase in ridership.

“Right now most of our routes run once an hour,” Lasher said. “For most people that’s not a viable option.”

But that doesn’t mean 50 percent more people took the bus, Lasher admitted.

Though it’s nowhere to be found on PSTA’s website or the PSTA-sponsored Pinellas Greenlight Plan’s website, ridership is calculated by adding the number of times a single person gets on a bus.

Transferring -- common for trips not running along straight bus routes -- increases ridership statistically even if it’s the same person. An individual who takes a round trip with two transfers accounts for four riders, according to PSTA’s math.

The new sales-tax-funded plan would decrease bus waiting times along core routes to between 10 to 15 minutes. The rest of the system still would have wait times between 30 minutes to an hour. Weekend bus services would increase by 80 percent.

PSTA is banking on people giving up their cars in exchange for more frequent bus services.

Many PSTA news releases from 2013 announced record ridership, strong demand for buses and boisterous support for the Greenlight Plan, which was authored by PSTA. In December, PSTA announced record ridership of 1.16 million, a 3.2 percent increase from December 2012.

“We’ve been experiencing overcrowding on many routes during the day for quite some time now, and the demand just keeps growing,” PSTA Chief Operating Officer James Bradford said in a statement.

Bradford’s claim was published next to a Pinellas Greenlight Plan advertisement and was based on anecdotal claims made by bus drivers.

The American Public Transportation Association, a Washington, D.C.-based nonprofit that advocates for public transit projects, estimates that only 45 percent of weekday transit ridership figures equates to actual people. Using PSTA’s numbers, that roughly translates to 640,000 transfers out of the reported 1.16 million December ridership total.

Pinellas County voters will decide the fate of the Greenlight Plan in a November referendum vote.

Contact William Patrick at wpatrick@watchdog.org or follow Florida Watchdog on Twitter at @watchdogfla.

Tags: News, Politics

Comments (3)

9:44PM JAN 27TH 2014
As more voters find out about the 14% sales tax increase to fund a light rail boondoggle, the more OPPOSE. Greenlight Pinellas has a 4th grade math problem.
Jennifer Cohen
1:41PM JAN 27TH 2014
I hope Pinellas says "YES" , we would love to see the rail continue South to North Port. Think of all the job opportunities that would open to graduating students. Build the rail!
10:11AM JAN 27TH 2014
If one looks at the actual costs of ownership for a car, a reasonable person would welcome good public transportation alternatives as a way to save a bunch of money. Car ownership is horribly expensive and if rather than having two or three or four cars having just one and using public transportation would keep a huge amount of money in peoples pockets to then be able to be used for other things.

Leave a Comment on This Story

The content of this field is kept private and will not be shown publicly.
To prevent automated spam submissions leave this field empty.