Columns

In Defense of Rick Scott

By: Joe Gruters | Posted: February 22, 2013 4:30 PM
Joe Gruters

Joe Gruters

Predictably enough, the media are having a heyday with Gov. Rick Scott’s decision to accept three years of federal funding for Medicaid under Obamacare, suggesting flip-flops and crass political maneuvering for re-election -- moving to the center. 

That is their spin. Some conservatives are understandably upset with Scott for not standing against the expansion on principle, feeling like he has betrayed them.

But here is a more full context. Painful as it is to admit, the Affordable Care Act, Obamacare, is the law of the land. With Obama’s re-election and the U.S. Supreme Court decision, the idea of it being overturned is now all but a pipe dream. However, if Republicans can win the White House and Congress, the worst parts may yet be able to be unwound.

And here is the point. The Medicaid expansion is not the worst part of the law. It was an existing program and the expansion is voluntary. Most states, Republican and Democrat, are going to accept the Medicaid expansion because it makes financial sense for the state.

While Obamacare overall remains unpopular -- and Scott remains opposed to the law and its intrusive elements -- the Medicaid expansion element of it is actually quite popular. It’s very popular in Florida, depending on how the poll question is asked.

About 1.3 million Floridians will get coverage, meaning billions of dollars will flow into the state’s already robust health care economy. That means jobs. Plus, Florida got a waiver it had been seeking to continue privatizing Medicaid for beneficiaries -- an important conservative principle.

Is Washington, D.C., totally irresponsible fiscally? Yes. Out of control? Obviously. That question answers itself. But Gov. Scott has no control over destructive, spend-happy politicians in D.C.

Hospitals throughout Florida routinely absorb the costs of providing health care to low-income people not on Medicaid who cannot or do not pay their bills. That drives up costs for everyone else and hurts hospitals financially. According to the hospitals, the Medicaid expansion should alleviate many of those costs while creating new jobs.

Scott has said that much of his opposition to the expansion in the past was based on the federal money running out after three years, and not wanting the state saddled with those expenses. A reasonable caution. But the state has the freedom under the law to back out in three years if the finances don’t work. That might be politically difficult, but if we work hard enough to get Scott re-elected, he will be in Tallahassee to make that call.

Further, because of the governor’s tough and sometimes unpopular choices in his first two years in office, the state is now looking at a surplus this year -- after having billions in deficits the previous years.

Scott does not get much credit in the media for balancing the budget that Gov. Charlie Crist left in shambles. He never will. But we know what he has accomplished with Republicans in the Legislature.

Scott’s own success with fiscally responsible decisions is what makes the Medicaid expansion an option now.

Simply stated: From a state point of view, the positives far outweigh the negatives:

-- billions of dollars flowing into the state;

-- thousands of jobs created;

-- people getting health care that may not have;

-- hospitals getting reimbursements they were not, making them healthier;

-- and an issue taken off the table that Democrats would surely have demagogued.

Gov. Scott has done a terrific job with what he promised to do. Reining in irresponsible federal spending was not among those promises.

Thanks for being informed and engaged.



Joe Gruters is chairman of the Republican Party of Sarasota.

Comments (16)

Conservative Voice
6:25AM FEB 26TH 2013
Joe, this is disgraceful. However, I expected nothing less from a man who has carried the RINO water for Vern Buchannon all these years. You should be proud of yourself Joe. You have risen in the ranks of the party doing the bidding of the party and refusing to waiver. You are in effect the perfect party man. You should go far. You are the next generation Jim Greer and John Thrasher. You will carry on the legacy those before you have built. That is defend the "R" let principals and values of conservatism be damned.
Frank
8:57AM FEB 26TH 2013
Got to love it - Republicans continuing to eat their own, once again . . . .

Pathetic, into obscurity . . .
bakersacres57
2:50PM FEB 25TH 2013
I thought this column was from The Onion. This site is Fun, and Funny. Joe must be a clown.
Richard Thomas
10:07AM FEB 25TH 2013
Yes, of course -- it's all the media's fault. What a stupid thing to write.
wbp
8:45AM FEB 24TH 2013
first the budget is balanced every yr by law. what he did is bal. the budget on the backs of people least able afford it, while sponsoring huge corporate giveaways. this piece is just campaign spin to get scott re-elected, which isn't going to happen. if obama had a 101 million dolaar slush fund to spend with little accountibilty the right would be hollowing, but it's ok for scott ?
D.A.
5:43PM FEB 23RD 2013
Yes, Rick Scott is right to now accept Federal funding. Too bad Florida lost billions of dollars because Rick Scott was wrong for the past two years.
P Walker
11:13PM FEB 22ND 2013
Wouldn't it be nice if we had a Governor and Representatives who recognized the damage the Fed does everywhere they stick their nose and stayed clear of all their "offers" like the poison they are. And had the guts to tell them to stay out of our state, we'll be better without them. The "billions flowing into the state" was taken from someone else first. Redistribution of wealth so the Fed can create jobs is a story we've heard time and time again. The private sector is much better at creating jobs than by redistribution of wealth by the Feds or State.. So now because a Republican Gov says it's a good idea to have others pay for others healthcare by force it's a positive. Hmm! Sounds like one of the driving forces within Obamacare; it was supposed to insure millions more while not costing more. Remember? Will the Republican Party ever again acknowledge less government is the best solution? Even if some "republicans" "justifiably" take the money Feds use to lure us all deeper and deeper into an abyss it's the same road. Republicans appear no different than the Democrats, fighting for more room at the federal trough with their own set of justifications.
David Jeffers
8:32PM FEB 22ND 2013
You should immediately resign for writing something like this.
David Jeffers
8:31PM FEB 22ND 2013
Yeah this doesn't cost Floridians anything because it's federal dollars...oh wait.
Lauretta A Peterson
8:16PM FEB 22ND 2013
This is the typical response: it is okay because it could be worse. Obamacare is a BIG deal and we want nothing to do with it. Missed opportunity and the voters are not happy. I give a darn what the "media: says, the voters are not dumb.
Bud Ennis
7:07PM FEB 22ND 2013
This a right on article. By getting the waiver to make Medicaid private you have insurance companies covering the Medicaid segment and the patients will have an Eight hundred number to call for customer service. Governor Scott did his research well and if it was not a good for Florida he would have turned it down no matter how much money would be coming from Washington. I like his dicision is based on principles of what is the best for Florida. Bud Ennis
Jack Lee
6:58PM FEB 22ND 2013
Rick Scott lost all of north Florida because of this Choice

RICK SCOTT JUST GAVE A HUGE HUG TO OBAMA. THIS WILL BE HIS DOWNFALL !!!

RICK SCOTT CAN NO LONGER BE TRUSTED
ALEN WEST FOR GOVERNOR 2014 !!!
Hug or Sleeping With
6:50PM FEB 23RD 2013
Charlie Crist gave Obama a hug. Scott decided to crawl into bed and redefine marriage between a man and a woman. Useful tools like Gruters can bend over and take it because he needs royal patronage from Scott to keep his unearned trustee seat. Does anyone else remember when Gruters carried Crist's water? I do... and so will everyone in 2014.
Betty Lou Bishop
6:25PM FEB 22ND 2013
Thank you for this logical explanation. I will pass this on to all
my Florida friends. I knew Gov. Scott must have had a good
reason to "flip-flop" on ObamaCare and this helps eleviate the
pain. We must get Repubicans elected in 2014 ... this should be
our goal!
P Walker
11:15PM FEB 22ND 2013
With Republicans like him we could just vote for a democrat
Grace Boyd
6:13PM FEB 22ND 2013
I know Governor Scott has done his best, but accepting the expansion of medicare was not one. Sometimes, standing on principle is worth the sacrifice. I am sorry, but I do not buy your argument. Robbing Peter to pay Paul is still not doing the right thing.

Grace Boyd

Leave a Comment on This Story

The content of this field is kept private and will not be shown publicly.
To prevent automated spam submissions leave this field empty.