Government

E-Verify Bill Dying a Slow Death in Senate

Tea parties are boiling over yet another GOP failure to clamp down on immigration
By: Kenric Ward | Posted: April 28, 2011 3:55 AM
E-Verify protestors in the CapitolE-Verify protestors in the Capitol Thursday | Photo: Gray Rohrer
Senate Bill 2040 must clear the Senate Budget Committee by day's end, according to the latest timetable. Still bottled up by Chairman J.D. Alexander, the heavily amended measure would require employers to use the federal E-Verify database or Real ID-compliant driver's license identification to screen new hires.

The driver's license alternative was added by Judiciary Chairwoman Anitere Flores, but the addition has not garnered support.

Democrats -- ever-attuned to the special pleading of migrant-rights groups, legal or illegal -- adamantly oppose any tightening of the rules.

Majority Republicans, who can pass legislation without any Democratic votes, have splintered amid pecuniary resistance from the Florida Chamber of Commerce, the Associated Industries of Florida, the agriculture industry -- and now, an onslaught of visiting immigrants.

On the other side, tea party groups have lobbied for E-Verify. Proponents note public-opinion polls showing support for tougher immigration laws at the state level.

Gov. Rick Scott also sent a strong signal that he supports the verification program with his executive order mandating its use in all state agencies under his control.

Speaking to a tea party rally on the Old Capitol steps on the opening day of the Legislature, Senate President Mike Haridopolos promised that his chamber would pass an E-Verify law (see video).

But since then, an E-Verify bill authored by Sen. Alan Hays, R-Umatilla, was absorbed into a Judiciary Committee bill, and then adulterated by Flores, R-Miami.

Despite Haridopolos' pledge, his appointee to the Judiciary chair, Flores, has made it clear that she is uncomfortable with immigration legislation. Her languishing committee bill is far weaker than the House version -- HB 7089 -- which pairs an E-Verify requirement with enforcement provisions that enable law-enforcement officers to tack on immigration charges during the course of a criminal investigation.

Floridians for Immigration Enforcement roundly criticized the Senate's tinkering with E-Verify. Advocates cited government studies pointing to the system's high accuracy rate and expanded use across the country.

"Because E-Verify addresses the root cause of illegal immigration -- the job magnet -- mandatory E-Verify for Florida is clearly the best solution to reduce the estimated $5.5 billion fiscal cost to Florida," said David Caulkett of FLIMEN.

Tea party groups across the state also support E-Verify.

Manatee Tea Party member Judith Hood called out Haridopolos in an April 20 letter:

"The decision is yours: side with the illegal aliens funded by George Soros, and aligned with Florida Immigrant Coalition, ACORN, ACLU, SEIU, and other organizations that want to destroy our state and country, or respect the rule of law, protect Florida taxpayers and get legislation passed protecting legal workers. Which will it be?"

Feeling the heat, Senate Republicans, many of whom campaigned for tougher immigration laws, have gone underground.

A Sunshine State News e-mail survey sent to all 28 Republican senators elicited just one affirmative response. Sen. Joe Negron, R-Stuart, said he would vote for SB 2040.

Meantime, Alexander and Haridopolos have entertained visits from legal and illegal immigrants at the statehouse.

Comments (21)

peter
6:23AM NOV 7TH 2011
I have really enjoyed reading your very well written blog posts. I will be your frequent visitor, that's for sure. mediahuset nova svindel
Lauren
3:41PM OCT 13TH 2011
Correction -- Rubio's RECORD speaks for itself. Until just a few months ago, Rubio got a grade of an F- by www.numbersusa.com for "failure to act". Now, he cosponsors ONE immigration bill and his grade is now a B-. What's up with that? Same thing with freshman US Rep David Rivera (RINO-FL), and Rubio's buddy in the FL legislature. Both of these RINO sellouts blocked six good illegal immigration bills similar to AZ and OK's...check it out for yourself. Records don't lie. The GOP is trying to do damage control in advance because they want their golden boy Rubio to run for national office. They know he can't with his crappy record on immigration. Look at TX Gov. Rick Perry. Lesson learned.
Lauren
3:34PM OCT 13TH 2011
To all you Marco Rubio worshippers -- just know that Rubio was one of the politicians who signed the pledge to OPPOSE E-VERIFY on "We Are Florida!" He talks a good game, but his respect speaks for itself, if anybody ever bothered to check it. The GOP and Tea Party's new golden boy is weaker on immigration than TX Gov. Rick Perry!!! Search it for yourself. As FL Speaker of the House in (07) he and several of his RINO Miami buddies conspired in advance of the legislative session to NOT allow the six tough illegal immigration bills "to see the light of day." Ha-ha. Real funny, huh? And, they didn't. And Rubio was elected as a "good conservative." My *ss.
12:04PM MAY 1ST 2011
The law is the law. FL legislators as such must obey and defend the law even though the Federal government is not enforcing the law. It is the duty of legislators to act in the best interests of the people in their state and that includes using their tax money wisely and honestly--using taxpayer dollars to support illegal immigration in the state to the tune of about 3 billion+/year is soft tyranny at best. It is the duty of FL legislators to stop corruption and letting unscrupulous businessmen to hire illegals hurts competition for all businessmen in FL and stifles a good economy. E-Verify is the fastest way to get those jobs back that illegals have stolen from Americans and legal workers in FL. FL as well as America as a whole cannot sustain a never-ending influx of illegal aliens economically, culturally, educationally, medically.

FL legislators should check their conscious very hard before they vote no for E-Verify. A "No" vote means that they favor illegal aliens in FL, who broke the law coming to FL and continue to do it every day they are here, over Americans and legal FL workers. FL legislators need to do what "THEY KNOW IS RIGHT". Floridians will back them for their courageous stand against corruption and tyranny against the American people. It's time for FL legislators to do what is best for Floridians and America as a whole. I feel to do otherwise is anti-American at the critical time when Floridians, at least 11% are unemployed and the rest of the population struggling, high gas prices, and a shaky and uncertain economy.

Fl legislators can begin to solve the problem that is a cancer in our society--illegal immigration must be cut-out to save our state and Nation.
Catherine
3:48PM APR 30TH 2011
What makes the posters believe E-Verify works so well? Have you actually read the research about it or the testimony on capital hill from the U.S.C.I.S. which administers the program? E-Verify does do well at verifying people that are legal, but it catches very few illegal aliens - with the primary reason that right now it cannot detect identity theft. So making it mandatory really just encourages increased identity theft. If you want to stop illegal immigration and illegal workers, you need to improve E-Verify's functionality before making it mandatory (USCIS is working on that) and couple it with comprehensive immigration reform. Anything short of that simply will not help the situation and could potentially make it worse.
Ellen Rentz
11:28AM APR 28TH 2011
It is not just Tea Party activist that agree with E-Verify. I believe a majority of the American people want tough immigration laws and mandatory E-Verify is a major step in stopping illegal immigration. No jobs - no illegals. And this old myth of they are working in the fields is just that, a myth. They are working anywhere that unscrupulous and greedy employers will hire them to work. And it's not just the burden that illegals place on all social services; very little of the money they earn stays here and they pay absolutely nothing into the system. Legal Americans need every available job and we have to stop employers from hiring illegals. Make the fines so stiff it will put them out of business if they violate them. Have a real guest worker program for agriculture and when the crops are harvested they go back where they came from until the next harvest. Put pressure on the Senate right now to pass the law with mandatory E-Verify!
Jaime
7:50PM APR 28TH 2011
Where are your grandparents from? Its not this cut and dry and people should become educated before they speak one sided.
ghostrideraz
1:19AM APR 29TH 2011
That does not matter "where does your Grand parents come from?" The truth of the matter is E-Verify works very well and a matter of fact that is why pro immagration folks are so against it.
This program works very here in Arizona and real citzens are coming back to work and the legal business are no longer getting underbidded by ilegal businesses. (no licience/insururance,ect)
Besides if you do not have a Visa and or a green card or permisssion to be in this country you are wrong and are breaking US Federal law. Thos same folks are probaly being provied all sorts of Welfare and Public asst. The final blow and slap to every American is they have stolen someones identity. We need to help our citzens who have paind taxes first not these ilegal people who are stealing!
Eastcoast
10:55AM APR 28TH 2011
It appears the only influence Senate President Mike Haridopolos will have at the end of this legislative session will be on how many highlights he puts in his hair.
10:14AM APR 28TH 2011
Why do lawmakers side with lawbreakers?.......Follow the money!
Sam Hoffman
9:10AM APR 28TH 2011
What, hold the presses, the Republican leadership lied?
Holy RINO crap, Batman!
Can it be that Cannon and Haridop are with the Penguin and Joker?
Stay tuned for the next episode...
generalno
8:47AM APR 28TH 2011
In denying the use of E-verify, Florida politicians have demonstrated their preference that its workforce steal, cheat and lie to acquire jobs. I doubt they'll be happy with the result in the work place and even unhappier at the next election.
saul
9:19AM APR 28TH 2011
Immigration is a tough issue. but this bill is a ludicrous solution.. It discriminates employee's. This bill will produce the same if not more problems than the Arizona bill. We are a beautiful state, let's find a more humane solution
generalno
12:22PM APR 28TH 2011
Would you open the border to all nations, or just to Mexico? E-verify simply automates the I-9 process already required by law. It does not discriminate because it applies equally to all and provides ample time to correct errors. It absolutely is not inhumane because sending illegal aliens back to their homelands simply corrects a wrong. On the other hand, it is inhumane to continuously take money from taxpayers to provide education, medical care, housing (Section 8), food (WIC) and general welfare (62%) to illegal aliens. And it's a gross injustice to the fine immigrants struggling to achieve their dreams legally. We need this law for many reasons not the least of which is to balance the budget.
Repubtallygirl
7:46AM APR 28TH 2011
The Senate President is demonstrating his total lack of control of the chamber. If he is this inept as Senate President, how does he expect to be a Senator. Doesn't look good.
Steve
6:56AM APR 28TH 2011
When did we lose our common sense? Our Government, has allowed the invasion of 30 million criminals in direct violation of Article IV, Section IV of our Constitution. they force American tax payers to pay Billions to provide Welfare, Prison cells, Educate the invaders children, free medical care,massive document fraud, & are destroying our schools, hospitals, communities, culture while Robbing, Raping, Killing & Assaulting American Citizens WAKE UP PEOPLE!
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=w9IGKRzdzZ8&feature=player_embedded
.youtube.com/watch?v=tsH8xvjTAlo
.youtube.com/watch?v=Btj6IeOFkis&feature=player_embedded
http://immigrationcounters.com/
.ojjpac.org/memorial.asp
.immigrationshumancost.org/
.newswithviews.com/Wooldridge/frosty580.htm
.youtube.com/watch?v=muw22wTePqQ
http://www.foxnews.com/us/2010/07/02/immigration-costs-fair-amnesty-educ...
http://www.rense.com/general81/dtli.htm
http://www.wnd.com/?pageId=41045
http://www.cairco.org/econ/econ.html
http://www.diggersrealm.com/mt/archives/003335.html
Every Non-representative including obama and holder should be IMPEACHED! for not upholding the oath of office they swore to defend the Constitution! If these clowns were to do their job, this would all be a Moot point!
Anchors and their criminal parents go, period, and cut the phony tears, you knew you were breaking the law when you crossed the border.

Next shut down any business hiring illegal labor. Oh and owners go to jail.
Got a better idea? Lets hear it!
Conservative
6:44AM APR 28TH 2011
Where is the Republican Leadership? Oh, thats right, there in the back pocket of special interests, not Floridians. Why aren't the conservatives raising holy-hell? Don't let these RINO's get away with sweeping this under the carpet. We is Mike Haridopolos when the citizens need him?
Common Sense
6:33AM APR 28TH 2011
Real simple Mike Haridopolos... your either with the law-abiding legal citizens of Florida or your with law-breaking illegal aliens. Simple.
WARNING
6:29AM APR 28TH 2011
If an immigration bill with strong e-verify language does not pass, the blood with fall on Mike Haridopolos' hands. His run for U.S. Senate will be over before it got started. Same on all the RINO's!
LDouglas
6:26AM APR 28TH 2011
"The prospect of no immigration legislation emerging this year will not sit well with conservative tea partiers who expected Republican lawmakers to break a string of nonproductive sessions on the issue."

It doesn't sit well with a lot of moderates either- and I know more than a few on the "left" who want E-verify passed as well.

What good is the legislature's efforts to create jobs at citizens expense and a better economy for Florida if they don't pass E-verify? With other states requiring it, that's just going to make the illegals head to Florida to look for work instead of going home.

And I believe that in turn will lead to the estimated $5.5 billion cost to taxpayers rising even more, as well as it resulting in more money taken away from being circulated in our economy. Keeping us in a constant state of needing more jobs, and tax money.
Angry Citizen
4:46AM APR 28TH 2011
If Mike Haridopolos cannot control his own "veto proof" majority in Florida how is he going to stand up to the sharks in Washington as a U.S. Senator? From the looks of this video it appears as though Haridopolos is one of those who say one thing in public but does another behind closed doors. I can see his opponents in the primary using his own words against him in carefully crafted campaign ads. No doubt they will take the conservative stand against illegal aliens. My vote is no for "Pretty Boy."