Columns

FAMU, Penn State Student Protests Misdirected

By: Nancy Smith | Posted: December 19, 2011 3:55 AM
I Beg to Differ

When did student protests, once incubators of social and political change in America, become little more than cheering sections for criminal behavior?

Recent protests involving students at Florida A&M and Pennsylvania State University make me wonder.

Let's have a quick look at Penn State first.

Penn State football's defensive coordinator Jerry Sandusky is a guy facing 40 counts of sexual abuse on underage boys.

Between 1994 and Nov. 5, 2011, when Sandusky was arrested, all kinds of Pennsylvania household names -- including the legend, Coach Joe Paterno -- were made aware more than once of Sandusky's lifestyle. But they did nothing, they let it happen, coddled Sandusky's lascivious secret without reporting him to the police.

Yet, what do Penn State students care about? Not the victims, it seems, just their own Shangri-La, their university's reputation and the loss of their beloved Coach Paterno.

Student protesters trashed their campus. They tore down lamp posts, flipped a news van, threw stones and bottles at reporters and blitzed Facebook with notes of support for their beloved Penn State.

And the alleged victims? What about them? It took weeks before alleged victims, members of an organization Sandusky founded for underprivileged kids, got a second look from university students.

The FAMU student protest a month later follows the murder of Florida A&M drum major Robert Champion.

The 26-year-old student was beaten so badly from the chest down that he died from shock caused by internal bleeding -- the victim of a suspected hazing incident within the school's famed marching band.

If you didn't know better, you might think student protests at FAMU over a thing like this are a natural.  After all, a little righteous indignation for the brutal culture of hazing at their school, involving their friends and classmates, is a good reason for students to get angry. So is the university administration's blind eye to a practice students acknowledge has been a way of life within the Marching 100 for many years.

But, no.

Curiously, FAMU students are protesting Gov. Rick Scott's recommendation that the university's president, James Ammons, be suspended while authorities conduct an investigation of problems and allegations at the school -- particularly within the band.

What we've got here is a mind-your-own business protest. It's a what-happens-in-Vegas kind of protest.

Apparently Scott was supposed to look the other way.

Apparently the death of a state university student in Florida falls exclusively under the jurisdiction of the Board of Governors and that's what fires up students these days -- not a fellow student's death, but jurisdictional geography. So, for butting in, Scott gets placard-carrying students chanting slogans and finding the time and the outrage to march on the governor's mansion.

Scott explained himself in some detail Sunday night.

“Following reports of the beating of one student and the death of another associated with hazing activities, I asked the Florida Department of Law Enforcement to provide any and all assistance necessary to help find answers through an investigation. After financial irregularities were discovered, I committed resources of our Inspector General to assist at the request of the Board of Governors.

“The FAMU Board of Trustees has already publicly reprimanded Dr. Ammons. This week, I learned of reports of at least one child molestation case that took place on campus, an incident Dr. Ammons told me in my office he was not made aware of until months after its occurrence. Based on all of these facts, I merely suggested it would be wise for Dr. Ammons to step aside until these investigations are completed."


Comments (13)

Joe S
5:48PM DEC 21ST 2011
Hello Nacy. I have a question. Were you at the psu "riot"? No you weren't. First off, students did not destroy the campus. The protest happened off campus. Second, of the 4,000 people there, 95% were peaceful observers. But you also did not see reporters behind the cameras pumping up the crowd like it was a football game. You did not see reporters telling kids what to say. You didn't see reporters encouraging kids to knock down a lamp-post. It was a protest against the media such as yourself. Don't rush to judge until all the facts have come out.
lpeoples61
12:44AM DEC 20TH 2011
Pure racism and double standard. If the FAMU President had been White (God Forbid!) he would have been whacked by the Board of Directors for not protecting his students. The FAMU protests were about Black Students and Black Alumni telling the "Whitey" Governor to mind his own business by staying out of theirs. Harsh words....but accurate!
Repubtallygirl
3:17PM DEC 21ST 2011
How dare a white Governor try to intervene when an 8-yr child is sexually molested, when a teenage girl has her leg broken, and the murder of a student through hazing?

What a racist.

Do you know how absolutely insulting your post is? I believe, you sir or ma'am, are the racist.
EddyJ
8:47PM DEC 19TH 2011
Was George W. Bush asked to resign for initiating a war on the false pretense of weapons of mass destruction? Did Presidents of the past step down when thousands of Blacks were beaten or lynched for simple acts such as exercising their right to vote? Did Scott call for the President of FSU to resign when 20 year old Ashley Cowie was killed and another student injured this past January at frat house? Another student was raped at the Strozier library on the FSU campus. How could the FSU President not know this was going on, and there were other rape victims too. Shouldn't he have thwarted these attacts. How about the Virginia Tech President? According to many, the student who killed 30+ people. Ammons should be given due process and in the end if he is proven negligent he should go.

What many should acknowledge is that he was not President when the other cases happened. The hazing of the young woman happened at one of the guys' apartment and she chose to go there twice. I'm sorry it happened to her and the drum major, but students are not supervised 24 hours. If that's the case then parents should also be held responsible if anything happens to their children regardless of where they are 24/7. None of the hazing incidents happened on campus, and the students all have to sign anti-hazing pledges. If students choose to pledge underground, the University should not be held responsible.

I truly hope all hazing ends, because it's ruined the lives of many good people.
Repubtallygirl
3:21PM DEC 21ST 2011
Ashley Cowie was killed in an accidental shooting, a HUGE difference from hazing. Mr. Champion was murdered and the thing you are about is protecting a failed university President who under his watch as experienced a teacher sexually molesting a student, a teenage girl getting her femur broke and the murder of a student.

He should be fired - FAMU has been nothing but a disgrace. The Marching 100 should be permanently disbanded.
Hermie
3:42PM DEC 19TH 2011
Nancy:

As a Penn State Alum I take offense to your article. Like most of the rest of the media the primary focus was to trash Penn State and not focus the attention on the people that were the cause of this travesty. Were you there the night of the riots when maybe 100 of the couple thousand students that gathered outside took place in the so called actual riots with some students actually being egged on by some of the media to cause trouble so they could get something on film? Were you there the night when over 10,000 students showed up at a candlelight vigil in support of the victims? Penn State is a world class institution that has been tarnished by the acts of certain administative individuals and smeared by the media to the point where everything Penn State is guilty. Hopefully, someday you will learn that a good writer will see both sides to the story. By the way, all catholic priests are pedophiles, right?
Get Real
11:13AM DEC 19TH 2011
Jim B. your lack of historical understanding and your playing of the left wing liberal and RINO Republican CARD is disgusting. I would, 1st suggest to you that you do some research on not only the history of Florida Higher Education, but also on race in Florida education and Higher education specifically, the role that it has played and continues to play.
Now, Nancy this article is void of any real substance what so ever, but then again in todays world FOX is regarded as news. For example, where was the outrage from the Gov. concerning the death of a UCF freshman in August of this year at a fraternity party of alcohol poisoning? Where was the Gov. then or more importantly where were you as a "journalist" searching for the truth? Where was the Board of Governors in 2008 when a UCF student died from hazing also at UCF? Where was the media and the GOV. calling for the head of the President of UCF?
It is clear that the state of Florida has a system of higher education and a process. That is what had the students protesting outside of the Gov. residence. The blatant disrespect of the system and the fact that never before has it been made in the face of tragedy as a back door attempt to circumvent the established processes and rule of law.
And contrary to the weak and lame attempt of the outside forces who attempt to disregard the role of race in the politics of Florida at every level, I ask you to simply Get Real.
Jim B.
5:26PM DEC 19TH 2011
Seriously? He asked them to suspend not to fire. They could have chosen to suspend with pay pending the outcome of the investigations. History has nothing to do with this, it is right vs. wrong. Your reference to FOX News just solidifies my statement.
Get Real
10:43AM DEC 20TH 2011
Suspending him is a back door way to fire him that is just a point of information and further more it is still out of line according to the Fl Constitution. (That is a little piece of paper that any other time is kinda important) However, I am more than adult enough to agree, even with people who I don't agree with. So, Jim B. I should have included the crap that passes as news on MSNBC and also CNN. Thank you for pointing out that I missed those and I am sure many other news junk that passes as journalism today.
Repubtallygirl
12:06PM DEC 19TH 2011
You should direct your questions to the Governor who was office in 2008. And that would be?
Get Real
10:45AM DEC 20TH 2011
Had you taken the time to read, I directed my question to the Board of Governors.
Jim B.
9:47AM DEC 19TH 2011
Nancy why don't you just come out and say it. We all know the reason they are up in arms. The Scott hatred has been and will continue to be driven by the left wing liberals and RINO Republicans who fear he will succeed. Now you throw in a traditional black school with same president and they can now use the race card against him.

No rather than do the right thing and demand answers and holding those who violate the law, they prefer to use this as an opportunity to attack Scott.

They couldn't care less about misuse of school funds, a beating of a female, a death of a student and the rape of a child. They the students and the media are as guilty as those who committed the crimes if they are not outraged.
Repubtallygirl
12:05PM DEC 19TH 2011
I couldn't have said it better myself.