Politics
FEC's Miami-Orlando Train Blows Past Treasure, Space Coasts
Around the State

Credit: konmesa - Shutterstock
"All Aboard Florida" would run on existing Florida East Coast Railway tracks between Miami and Cocoa, and then use some 40 miles of new rails to connect inland to Orlando.
FEC Industries' announcement of the route last week initially excited Treasure and Space coast residents who have been without coastal rail service since Amtrak departed in 1968.
But FEC officials say their plans do not envision any stops between West Palm Beach and Orlando.
By minimizing stops, the trains could average speeds of 100 mph, said spokeswoman Christine Barney. That would be far faster than the Amtrak service that connects South Florida and Orlando via an interior route.
"We're trying to do what makes the most sense to deliver the most travelers," Barney said, adding that additional terminals haven't been ruled out.
Kim Delaney, of the Treasure Coast Regional Planning Commission, has worked with FEC and Amtrak to explore a return of passenger rail service to Martin, St. Lucie and Indian River counties.
"Clearly, the FEC is interested in passenger service, and hopefully this will help expedite intercity passenger service along Florida’s East Coast," Delaney said.
She emphasized that FEC's initial announcement "does not preclude any other passenger service being contemplated on the FEC Railway.”
On Friday, the Space Coast Transportation Planning Organization will host a rail information meeting at Daytona Beach City Hall.
The gathering -- part of an ongoing campaign by beachside communities to revive coastal train service north to Jacksonville -- is scheduled to hear representatives from Amtrak and the state Department of Transportation.
FEC's Miami-Orlando route, with an estimated price tag of $1 billion, is billed as a private venture by FEC. Both FEC Industries and FEC Railway are majority-owned by funds managed by Fortress Investment Group, headquartered in New York City.
"There would be no risk to state," Barney said. "The vast majority of construction will be privately funded."
She added, however, it was "too early to say what minor contributions may come from the the public sector." She said there had been no discussions with Amtrak, but that FEC is "open to any options that make sense."
Karen Jarosh, who helped lead the No Tax for Tracks campaign against a light rail project in Hillsborough County, called the east coast project "great news if this is truly private."
But she remains skeptical until an in-depth ridership study is conducted.
"They are showcasing jobs and environment which seems geared more for government pursestrings than the eyes of investors or potential passengers," Jarosh said.
"They tout 240 miles in three hours with frequent service, and I'm thinking this is new packaging of the high-speed rail plans Floridians have rejected several times over and will require billions in federal funds to get off the ground."
Barney acknowledged that ridership and engineering studies have yet to be performed, but she said that Miami and Orlando -- large population and tourism centers -- appear to make a high-speed line financially feasible.
"There could be 50 million potential riders a year," she said.
By contrast, the middle coastal counties north of Palm Beach are more suburban/rural, and not exactly high-volume tourist meccas. The combined population of Martin, St. Lucie, Indian River and Brevard counties is barely 1.1 million spread over 2,633 square miles.
Brevard alone accounts for roughly half the region's population. The Brevard city of Cocoa is envisioned as the turning point for the railroad's pivot between Orlando and the coast, though Barney said there were no plans for a passenger service there.
Leigh Holt, spokeswoman for the Space Coast Transportation Planning Organization, said she thought it was "curious" that FEC made its announcement without first speaking to Brevard County officials. Holt said the county has yet to hear from FEC.
--
Contact Kenric Ward at kward@sunshinestatenews.com or at (772) 801-5341.

Comments (5)
Other points: Amtrak will also operate its New York-Florida train(s) over the FEC between Jacksonville-Miami and they will likely serve stops skipped by FEC trains. Even so, some FEC trains may indeed serve some intermediate destinations as time goes on. Tri-Rail will also keep expanding north---they already are calling for service to Jupiter.
We may end up with FEC corridor service Miami-Orlando and Miami-Jacksonville, with more intermediate stops for some trains, thru Amtrak service Miami-Jacksonville-New York and Homestead-Miami-W Palm Beach-Jupiter service on Tri-Rail. BTW, don't be surprised if FEC goes directly to downtown Miami instead of the current Amtrak/Tri rail stop near Miami International airport and some Tri Rail service as well. The former site of the FEC station is in the heart of downtown and has both a Miami Metro and downtown people mover stops nearby. Very convenient.
As for intermediate stations, they WILL happen. This is a corridor service and that will involve more then trains running straight through from end to end non-stop. If the point is just to serve Orlando and Miami, an airplane could do a better job, but the strength of rail is it's city center to city center delivery of passengers.. While there might indeed be a few non-stop trains, non-stop is the realm of jet aircraft.
This is one of the great failures of the Amtrak system. When it was first conceived, Congress threw out a handful of what they called 'end point cities,' then told an embryonic rail system to connect the dots. Trains stop in Palatka, Sebring, Lakeland and Deland for a reason, that reason is to serve a demographic that cannot use, or has no access to an airport.
Traditional railroad stations along the line from Jacksonville were:
St. Augustine
Bunnell
Ormond Beach
Daytona Beach
New Smyrna Beach
Titusville
Cocoa-Rockledge
Eau Gallie
Vero Beach
Fort Pierce
Stuart
Hobe Sound
West Palm Beach
Lake Worth
Delray Beach
Boca Raton
Pompano Beach
Fort Lauderdale
Hollywood
North Miami
Miami
My professional opinion is that when all of these proposals break ground the lure of millions more potential passengers in places like Daytona Beach, Jacksonville and Tampa will be too great to ignore.
Don't be surprised when the FECI trains start rolling that from 3 to 5 of them continue north from Cocoa to Jacksonville. Likewise when Sunrail starts up and 3 or 4 of their trains run through to both Jacksonville and Tampa. Add to that Amtrak, the need for a train through the central spine of the state (Gainesville-Ocala-Dade City), a possible restoration of the 'Sunset Limited' Jacksonville-New Orleans, a much talked about and needed train beyond Jacksonville to Atlanta.... FECI knows how to run a railroad, and they're not going to sacrifice station stops that could generate revenue for the benefit of a few jet set customers that don't understand what Intercity Rail is.
For more insights visit me at:
Metro Jacksonville . com
or
Jacksonville Transit @ blogspot . com
Remember this, Disney is connected to the ships at Port Canaveral and Orlando International Airport is between them. It would be a lot cheaper with quicker trip times for the train to leave Orlando and go directly south southeast to West Palm. Fact is they wouldn't be making the circuitous jog to Cocoa-Rockledge if they didn't have a plan for a station there.
Leave a Comment on This Story