Columns

Florida Education Is Doing Something Very Right

By: Jeb Bush | Posted: September 15, 2012 3:55 AM
Jeb Bush

Jeb Bush

I recently had the honor of speaking at the Republican National Convention joined by a dedicated teacher and a first-generation college graduate. 
 
Sean Duffy talked about the rewards of educating young minds and Frantz Placide the blessings of receiving that education. This magic plays out in Florida’s best classrooms every day. Numerous studies and statistics document the amazing progress of Florida schools and students in the past 12 years. But what’s behind those studies is most important -- the flesh-and-blood results in students’ lives when political leaders make children the priority in our schools and great teachers rise to the challenge.
 
Florida has gone from a national disgrace in education to a national model for reform. Since the 1990s, our students now rank second nationally in learning gains. By demanding that schools ensure these children can read in the elementary grades, we are seeing them show up years later in high school Advanced Placement courses. Florida now ranks sixth nationally in the percentage of high school students graduating with the successful completion of an AP course. Our graduation rate is rising much faster than the national average despite more rigorous standards.
 
There are two lessons to be learned from this. What we are doing is working. And we still have a very long way to go. Only one-third of our students who earn a high school diploma are ready for college.
 
Florida’s package of reforms includes school choice, higher standards, accountability, transparency, better trained teachers, digital learning and funding that is targeted at programs that produce results.
 
What do we still need to do? Give parents more choice. Raise the standards even higher. Give parents whose children are in failing schools a stronger voice in correcting the problem. Expand digital options. Recognize and reward student learning instead of funding schools based on seat-time. Reward the best teachers and weed out more of the ineffective ones. 
 
When we started on this course in 1999, we were considered radical. Now many of these reforms are mainstream and increasingly bipartisan.
 
Despite this, there will be efforts to roll back some of our most important accomplishments in next year’s legislative session, not because they aren’t working for children but because they are creating discomfort for adults. The Florida Education Association once again is arguing that we need to go back in the direction of a failed past -- not surprising in that the teachers’ unions bitterly fought every successful reform since the movement began. The Florida School Boards Association also hopes to dilute accountability reforms in next year’s legislative session. If the school boards had done their job by cracking down on failing schools and ensuring all children received an education, then there wouldn’t have been a need for the reforms the boards now seek to escape. 
 
The evidence is as clear as it is overwhelming. Education reform is working for all students, especially for those low-income children who had been neglected for decades because the education bureaucracy had the option of ignoring them. Accountability, transparency and competition have proven to be powerful motivators. Monopolies, failure factories and social promotion have proven to be disastrous for entire generations of our most vulnerable kids.
 
The direction to go is forward, not backward.
 


Jeb Bush was governor of Florida from 1999-2007 and is the chairman of the Foundation for Florida’s Future.

 

Comments (7)

Dave Galloway
11:08AM SEP 16TH 2012
JEB!,
Now that public education in Florida is reaching the tipping point to ruin and is in fact being shoved over the cliff by Scott and his legislative henchmen as we speak. Maybe, finally you will go away. Your plan to "proft-tize" (that's a word your brother can be proud of) public education has proven to be an EPIC Fail. Except of course for your other brother Neal, Pearson Inc. and others who continue to siphon away precious tax dollars from schools and kids . . .
Great American
11:18AM SEP 18TH 2012
Let me guess socialist borderline communist who probably lives on welfare because you are too lazy to work or you haven't amount to much and you envy those who study work hard and have great jobs. Stop blaming the Bush bros. and open your eyes to what our country
and our people have become "COMPLACENT"
Thomas Ho
4:45AM SEP 16TH 2012
The comments illustrate the point I've made to encourage the use of technology to complement the student assessment and teacher evaluation mechanisms which have divided those of us who care so much about education.

So, education reform can be very adversarial. This situation is exacerbated for those of us “on the outside looking in” because we have little first-hand experience and we don’t know who to believe among those who do! Thus, there’s a critical need for more transparency!

What do I mean by that and HOW can we accomplish it? First, why can’t we achieve more transparency of student learning to provide evidence of student learning to relieve the pressure on high-stakes testing to assess learning? Among other alternatives, technology offers such an opportunity:
Social media can be used to create learning artifacts to assess learning and to enable students’ positive digital identities
Electronic portfolios serve as a repository for learning artifacts

Second, why can’t we achieve more transparency of teacher performance to provide evidence of student learning to relieve the pressure on high-stakes testing to assess teachers? Teacher professional development “screams” for social media because it can provide evidence of professional development to complement other evidence such as students’ performance on high-stakes tests.
Diane Hanfmann
11:56PM SEP 15TH 2012
Hmmm. hasn't anyone informed Mr. Bush that a lawsuit is proceeding as to the adequacy of Florida's education? Why does he fail to recall that Florida's Seniors scored below the national average in both Reading and Math on the 2009 NAEP? Only 2 other states of the 11 participating states performed as dismally and I doubt those students had to undergo so many of Jeb's failed strategies for so many years to do so badly. Does Jeb forget the FCAT reading inflated scores, the year when Superintendents voiced lack of confidence in the FCAT results, and the amazing yet unknown to me part of the A+ Plan where standardized test results which are derived from a different test administered under different conditions yield far different results which are then magically chnaged via a phone call. Does Jeb recall that Florida was pursued by the ACLU for poor graduation rates or has that escaped his consciousness? How did he forget the defeat of Senate Bill 6? Has the defeat of the parent trigger bill escaped his reality? Has he been out of town while districts signed resolutions against high stakes testing in his state? How did he miss the judge knocking down 736? Yes, Jeb, Florida is doing something right....REBELLING against your bad policies. Wake up and smell the dissent. ALEC is no secret any longer, nor is the push to sell our state's children's minds to the lowest bidder so profiteers can flourish.
Bryan Bouton
5:54PM SEP 15TH 2012
I guess blaming teachers for all the woes and troubles with schools just isn't working...since all those parents are coming forward to decry your "reform" methods as simply enrichment for testing companies and failing charter schools...
and now you bring blame on the duly elected members of every school board in the 67 counties in this state?...geeze, as Sheriff Bart said: "can't you see this is the last act of a desperate man?"...(and yes, I worked a Blazing Saddles/Mel Brooks quote into a comment about education...you GOTTA appreciate that!)
Thomas James
12:17PM SEP 15TH 2012
Jebby's privatization agenda continues to unravel. Of course the only people hurt are the students who have been turned into test lab rats and the teachers who continue to be demonized by the GOP's oppressive anti public education agenda.
Jebby's dirty little secret is Florida's average SAT and ACT test scores continue to DECLINE under his FCAT frenzied policy. Why are we spending 75% of our time, money and energy on the bottom 25% when we should be spending it on the 75% of kids who actually want to learn.
Conservative Voice
7:26AM SEP 15TH 2012
Jeb, I am a conservative and have always supported your brother when it came to protecting our country. However, I am really tired of listening to your comments about the conservative movement in this country. You had an opportunity to run for the Senate and almost assure a victory over Bill Nelson. Yet your selfishness and ego prevented you from doing so. Now we have Connie Mack which, in my opinion, will hand the Senate seat back to Nelson.

You lead off speaking about Sean Duffy who joined you on the stage of the Republican Convention. The man did not have the common decency to wear a suit while speaking to the millions watching, he then gave an interview with Politico stating that he would probably vote for Obama. A man who is going to vote for a failed president that has done great harm to our country is allowed to speak at the most important event of the Republican Party is beyond words. In my opinion, this casts great doubt on your judgement.

You are now the self inflicted expert on education. My guess is that you are angling for the Department of Education, the very agency most conservatives agree should be eliminated. Thanks for nothing.

Leave a Comment on This Story

The content of this field is kept private and will not be shown publicly.
To prevent automated spam submissions leave this field empty.