Columns

Florida Media, Rick Scott and the Poll Position

How establishment press sets up a news template that produces 'failure'
By: Kenric Ward | Posted: May 25, 2011 12:14 PM

Kenric Ward 150x207Kenric Ward
The Tallahassee press corps could barely contain its orgasmic outpouring in reporting Gov. Rick Scott's latest poll numbers Wednesday. The only thing missing was a comparison to Adolph Hitler's lagging popularity in the dying days of the Third Reich, though I may have missed that angle amid the effusion.

For the mainstream media, it was mission accomplished. Reporters and opinion writers -- a thundering herd of not-so-independent thinkers -- have been gunning for Scott since he burst onto Florida's political scene a little more than a year ago.

His victory last fall sent the scribes into apoplexy, and since then, Scott has been the target of unrelenting negative coverage. The governor stands accused of "cutting" education, "slashing" services for the young, the elderly and the disabled, "waging war" on public employees, "suppressing" votes, and, worst of all, ignoring the press.

Whether it's his private jet, his personal wealth or his corporate (horrors!) background, Scott is alternately portrayed as clueless or criminal. Actual facts are optional.

Broad-brush, ad hominem attacks have a way of sinking in when they are part of the daily media narrative. That narrative shapes public opinion, and public-opinion polls.

Decidedly Democratic and left-leaning, reporters and editors seize on selected events to burnish their liberal template. After a Democrat won the mayoral race in Jacksonville this week, the election predictably morphed into a referendum on Scott.

In fact, the governor spent less than a day campaigning on Mike Hogan's behalf, and there were plenty of other players (and issues) deserving far more blame (or credit) for the outcome.

Then there was the ginned-up story about Scott's presidential prospects. The premise began with a thumb-sucking piece concocted by a political writer, who quickly knocked down his own straw man as "absurd." In true Pavlovian fashion, the media hounds descended on the governor's office for comment ... and then mocked the very notion that Scott would consider himself White House timber. (He doesn't, by the way.)

Then came this week's Quinnipiac Poll, which showed Scott's disapproval rating rising to 57 percent. No surprise there, given the foregoing media "treatment."

The dreary news, naturally, made big headlines and fueled Twitter feeds, where an incestuous mix of political strategists and journalists preens for stories and "insights."

So let's put Scott's negative number in context. It's roughly the same as the Republican-led Legislature, and it's not far off President Barack Obama's 52 percent disapproval rating in Florida.

Yet Quinnipiac's April poll on Obama got comparatively little play, and there was virtually no discussion of the finding that 51 percent of Floridians don't think the president deserves a second term. In short, it was treated as an aberration, whereas Scott's poll numbers represent a fatally toxic "trend."

Bottom line: "All the News That's Fit to Print" has become "All the News That Fits the Narrative."

It would be easy for conservative and independent voters -- who represent a majority of Floridians -- to be flummoxed or discouraged by this setup. But the reality is that as the Old Media loses its grip on reality, it's losing market share and influence as well. 

Scott didn't receive a single endorsement from the reactionary liberals who constitute newspaper editorial boards in this state. They remain stuck in amber of the '60s while the readership and life move on.

--

Contact Kenric Ward at kward@sunshinestatenews.com or at (772) 801-5341.




Comments (9)

Arthur Howard
1:06AM MAY 27TH 2011
Kenrick Ward,from the way you write you must admire Herbert Hoover also!Rick Scott won by a very slim margin and now he acts as if he has some mandate.Perhaps he feels he does with his blatant corporate welfare agenda's.This guy is as total disaster and you have the gull to blame it at least in part on the "liberal media"!Have you no shame sir,no sense of real decency?Are you just a lame partisan yourself?From your obvious way of thinking it seems both applies to you!
BM
3:52PM MAY 25TH 2011
Mr. Ward thank you for taking your profession on when they all have seemed to jump into the gutter of despair.

As far as the poll numbers are concerned, what do they expect? They constantly badger every word, every sentence and every move. As for the idiot "columnist" throwing out the run for president, I believe that was Adam Smith who had not been right on his reports in years. He manufactures news for his own personal enjoyment.

Now back to the polls. When was the last time polls balanced a budget, promoted economic development, or made a difficult decision?

I stand with Governor Rick Scott and I stand with him proudly!
mary repar
2:10PM MAY 25TH 2011
Awww...are we feeling put upon? Republicans should quit whining over the treatment they get from being who they are--uncompassionate, wealth-stealing, unpatriotic (causing our national security to be undermined by their relentless pursuit of money and tax breaks at any cost, economic and/or social), dysfunctional (cognitive dissonance ring a bell?!?), destructive, etc., etc., etc., power hungry, etc. If you can't take the heat, don't get into politics.

Whiners. Republicans can pile it on but they can't take it when it comes back to bite them. Liberal media indeed! Just look who owns the "liberal" media and the truth is out--Clear Channel, Rupert Murdoch, etc., ring any bells! Duh!!!
LDouglas
1:32PM MAY 25TH 2011
"The governor stands accused of ..."

Mr. Ward, you forgot, deflowering the environment. (Which does remain to be seen...) Anyhow, I'm not one of his biggest fans (he still has time to prove himself) but I have to admit some in the press have been very harsh to him. It's one thing for editorial boards to criticize his policies and direction and another to call him names. But rather than seeing it as them stuck in the 60's (I didn't read newspapers then so maybe I don't know) it seems they're too much 2010's- like their trying to capture more of the reality TV viewing set.
Tea Partier
12:49PM MAY 25TH 2011
GO RICK! Tea Party has your back!
tallanh
2:35PM MAY 25TH 2011
Oops, Rick! Look who's behind you! Given that a majority of Americans have had a negative opinion of the Tea Party for some time now, their support may be toxic!
Deloris Marchesiello
4:49PM MAY 25TH 2011
You are very wrong about the TEA PARTY.
Jack Gillies
12:47PM MAY 25TH 2011
Great perspective Kendric! Keep reporting the truth.