Columns

Florida Republicans: New Era or Same Old Stuff?

Amid token talk about 'Hispanic friends,' tea parties are steaming and Greer's ghost lurks
By: Kenric Ward | Posted: January 17, 2011 3:55 AM
Kenric WardKenric Ward

Outgoing state Republican Party Chairman John Thrasher worries that the GOP "is taking our Hispanic friends for granted."

Reaching out, at least rhetorically, to the nation's fast-growing voting bloc has emerged as Talking Point No. 1 with Republicans these days. Yet, Thrasher's appeal was tinged with irony.

The only Hispanic to speak during the RPOF's chairman election on Saturday was state Sen. Anitere Flores, who delivered the nominating speech for Sarasota County party chairman Joe Gruters.

Flores' appeal fell on deaf ears as Gruters finished a distant third in the five-way contest.

Likewise, Gruters' call to reach out to "tea party and 9/12 groups" landed with a thud. It was the one and only mention of the conservative grass-roots network that helped to propel Rick Scott to victory -- and it got zero applause.

Though party leaders pay ceaseless lip service to "grass-roots," they're not necessarily in sync with the conservative base. That disconnect was on display in Orlando last weekend when party delegates elected Dave Bitner chairman.

Of the five candidates, Bitner was the most Tallahassee-centric. The former four-term state representative-turned-lobbyist resides in neighboring Jefferson County, hardly a hotbed of Hispanic diversity.

Adding to the insider intrigue, Bitner's fifth wife, Wendy, now handles the lobby list (wink, wink).

Bitner was the least specific about his plans for the party -- and no one seemed to mind. While Deborah Cox-Roush struck an independent and increasingly combative pose ("I don't owe anyone anything") and Sid Dinerstein relentlessly recited his "seven steps for ethical health," the delegates just yawned.

Gruters was praised during the gubernatorial campaign by Scott, who said, "We all know that the next chairman of the Republican Party ought to be Joe, because he has done such a wonderful job in Sarasota."

Tony DiMatteo strove for street cred with the party faithful when he read a laudatory letter from Marco Rubio. DiMatteo was the first RPOF hopeful who dared to jump off the Charlie Crist bandwagon and support Rubio for U.S. Senate.
But none of this mattered.

Though the governor is the titular head of the party, Scott evidently sensed he was outgunned in the chairman's race and did not reiterate his praise for Gruters in Orlando. DiMatteo, it turns out, was never a contender.

Bitner, wrapping himself in the flag of matrimony and faith, testified to delegates before the vote that the two most important people in his life are "my wife and Jesus Christ."

Infused with the requisite emotion, a choked-up Bitner kept his remarks brief and generic prior to the vote. After the ballots were tallied, he said, "I took the high road."

Did Bitner's gauzy strategy sway the delegates on Saturday -- or were their minds already made up? Since few, if any, were willing to be quoted before the election, it's hard to know for sure.

It's also difficult to gauge the impact on Hispanic Republicans going forward. Flores, who owes her Judiciary Committee chairmanship to Senate President Mike Haridopolos, isn't saying either way.

Rick Wilson, a Tallahassee-based GOP media strategist, predicted, "Bitner will do well. He understands the needs of the party and has both the political and fund-raising skills to get us in a strong  position.

"Given that Florida is the battleground state in 2012, I think he was absolutely the right choice."

Tea partiers are less enthused.

Tom Tillison, a leader of the Central Florida Tea Party Council, said, "The RPOF is still dominated by the old-guard establishment. Is it then surprising that they elect one of their own?"

Comments (12)

Samson
12:02PM FEB 4TH 2011
No, you're not going to get anything new until we have new parties in charge. Like the Tea Party. The repubicans and democrats have had their day, time for something new. Vote Tea 2012!
Smithy
10:18AM FEB 4TH 2011
Show me someone who thinks this is a new era for republicans, and I'll show you someone with their head in the sand. I know for a fact, the republican party is just as bad, if not worse, then before the tea party came along. Now the grassroots conservatives have painted a target on their backs, and it says Tea Party. Unless your their "kind of tea party" member you won't win any races or hold any position of power in the republican party. That's why the Tea Party should stand on it's own, and run it's own candidates, and to hell with the republicans.
John Casey
5:33PM FEB 1ST 2011
Tom Tillison is a joke, he's paid republican operative and a political hack. He's no more a tea party activist then I'm the tooth fairy. Just look at the person he supported for governor, Bill McCollum! McCollum is the poster child of "old-guard establishment" politics. And this is the person you, and you "tea party" support for the governor's mansion! What a joke.
Capt. America
5:26PM FEB 1ST 2011
Of course it's the same old crap with the republicans, all the "tea party backed" candidatews lost. The republican party is never going to change it's ways, because they don't have the guts to stand-up for whats right, all they care about is getting re-elected. That's the main reason the Tea Party needs to be it's own party and stay that way. The Florida Tea Party is alive and doing well under the leadership of Peg Dunmire and we will hear from them in 2012, because the republicans have not learned their lesson at all.
Willy
5:29PM JAN 29TH 2011
The problem with the republicans is that the party bosses are getting more, and more power, and the people are losing more, and more of there voice. Power corrupts, and the RPOF has more power now then ever before. The Tea Party didn't get any applause because they know THEY are the reason the Tea Party is around. If the GOP was doing it's damn job, there would be no Tea Party. And they're angry that the people are watching closer than ever, which makes it harder to do their dirty work.
Sonny
2:36PM JAN 29TH 2011
As a Hispanic republican, and tea party member, I am appalled at the corruption the republican party is showing in the chairmanship nomination process. We in the Hispanic community value transparency above all. If your trying to court the Hispanic vote, just be real, don't try to tell us what you think we want to hear. We'll see right through you, and we won't like it. The RPOF is nothing but a brood of vipers, and two-faced yes-men, That's why thr Hispanic community does not find the republican party appealing.
Tom Hurchens
6:36PM JAN 17TH 2011
This article is on point, not surprised the establishment went with one of thier own, once again ignoring the grass roots wishes. What I was surprised about was that all 10 Rick Scott appointees also united for the government insider. I thought Rick was the outsider we sent to clean up Tallahasse.
Curtis Sliwage
2:03PM JAN 17TH 2011
Hopefully, Hispanic voters (just like the rest of us middle class voters) realize that the GOP will give them lip service in order to get their votes. Once elected, the GOP continues to be the representatives of the wealthiest 2% of Americans. All of their motivations are toward making the rich become even richer (often at the expense of the middle class taxpayers). The hard work and strong patriotism always exhibited by middle class Americans is not respected and actually means nothing to the arrogant, out of touch with the middle class, corporate rich kids who dominate the Republican Party. (BTW, I have been a member of the GOP for 34 years but have become increasingly disenchanted as I see how the GOP is against all that is good for middle class workers: unions, living wages, good benefits, retirement at a reasonable age, pensions, social security, medicare, etc.)
Phil Frommholz
12:11PM JAN 17TH 2011
It is unfortunate that the RPOF members did not give much credit to the Tea Party groups. In Sarasota, Gruters backyard, as a member of the Tea party groups and REC champion, I did most of my recruiting from the Tea Party groups. The Tea Party members were the workhorses of the party in both the primary and the mid-terms. We would have not seen the sweeps that we acheived without the dedicated Tea Party members. Unfortunately, the old guard Sarasota republicans contributed little in work to the successes we achieved. Joe and many of us assumed that our successes gained from newcomers were representative of successes in other counties. If the old guard wants to winn in 2012 they have a choice, they can work or get out of the way. We can't afford to lose the next round or we are finished as a state and a country.
LDouglas
9:26AM JAN 17TH 2011
It may turn out good. Seems like Bitner follows the "if at first you don't succeed, try, try again" motto- seeing how he's on wife #5. ;-) ;-)

Otherwise, I just read there is a growing number of Hispanic muslims in America. (And a shrinking number of Catholics.) I'm curious to see if that trend continues, how that'll work for the Republican party.
BM
5:48AM JAN 17TH 2011
As the saying goes Same Stuff, Different Day. There will still be payoffs and there will still be back room deals. Just not, no one will care.

As far as the Tea Party (movement, not political party) is concerned, the sooner they realize that the Republican Party is not their friends the better. You see they see the Tea Party as a threat to their system of doing things. They do not like that at all.
corneo
5:30AM JAN 17TH 2011
I'm confused. I never knew the 9/12 or tea party had any bearing on the RPOF or it's actions. Did they change and the news media didn't print it? Are they now a political organization?