Columns

Gov. Rick Scott, Hero; Press Corps, Zero

By: Nancy Smith | Posted: January 31, 2011 3:55 AM
New Heroes and Zeroes
Thank God we found out Thursday night that the governor and his guests "dined on mesquite grilled swordfish, corn macque choux, and Florida strawberry shortcake."

Or did they?

Can the people of Florida be absolutely sure? What if diners were really inside that mansion chowing down on roast beef, spinach casserole and English trifle?

How might that have torpedoed the ship of state?

Luckily, we had reporters from The Miami Herald, St. Petersburg Times and others in the press corps to confirm the menu.

None of them were dinner guests, mind you, but it wasn't for lack of trying. More about that later.

Noses pressed against the front gate of the governor's mansion, seething and twittering and probably freezing, a group of the press corps' most diligent reporters waited the two or three hours it took for diners inside to take a tour of the residence, eat and share stories. It was their journalistic obligation, to be sure.

Finally, when the front door of the mansion opened and guests emerged and made their way to the gate, the tsunami of reporters engulfed them. All but one of them.

That would be me.

I had been inside the mansion, too. I was one of the governor's guests. I am, or was – technically, anyway -- part of the press corps.

Gov. Rick Scott | Credit Colin HackleyGov. Rick Scott
Yet, I managed to pass by the crowd outside unimpeded, asked not a single question by reporters who were busy getting details of what went on inside from the three legislators among Gov. Rick Scott's six dinner guests.

In case you didn't catch that, allow me to repeat it: They were asking the three legislators, not the person in the press corps, what was discussed inside the mansion.

The legislators they are committed to “watch.”

The reason they wanted to be inside the mansion, remember?

I had been right there, walked right past them. Not a question was I asked.

This tells you a couple of things about how the media elite think and how they cover the Tallahassee landscape these days:

  • They don’t think conservative Sunshine State News’  journalistic ethics rise to their gold standard. That’s why they truly believe, even with 42 years as a newspaper journalist, if asked what went on in the mansion, Nancy Smith would probably lie.
  • Sunshine is in the tank for Rick Scott. After all, it failed to defend the media’s anti-Rick Scott editorial board positions during the elections, relentlessly picked on their darlings Bill McCollum and Alex Sink in columns, and most offensive of all, Sunshine staffers trust their readers – not the press corps – to tell them if they’re operating responsibly and ethically and if they’re getting the news right.

Here's the bottom line: Anybody with a fully oxygenated brain can see that the media elite in Tallahassee are a dysfunctional family of spoiled children. Until Rick Scott’s inauguration, they called the shots. They had friends in Capitol offices to help them get information, gain access, trade favors. They made the rules.

Doesn’t happen so much anymore. Scott makes the rules now. He brought in a lot of new people, chased out many of the old staff, leaving the press corps at square one to forge relationships all over again.

Other governors, Charlie Crist in particular, “invited reporters to attend social meetings at the mansion” – as one irritated reporter put it. But the word the reporter left out was “hand-picked.” Crist hand-picked the reporters he invited. He most certainly had his favorites.

Comments (16)

JeZim
8:06PM FEB 10TH 2011
Journalism rule No. 1 -- Never make yourself the story. I couldn't get to the heart of this piece for all the ego and self-righteousness in the way. ... Hardly a journalist left standing who knows how to simply REPORT the news without stumping for his/her own position.
Ronald Coleman
3:14PM FEB 6TH 2011
Boy,
If I were in Governor Scotts press corp, This local rag,Mullet wrapper would be the last to have access to news here in Ta llahassee.
This "paper", has done nothing but ridicule,berate,cast snide and hateful remarks.Every article they have put out has a put down in it.
"Let them eat crumbs"
10:31AM FEB 3RD 2011
I sent you an email already Ms Smith but obviously after reading you article again you do not study history. Especiall history about WW11 and the Nazi regime. Hitler (and I hate like hell using this) set up a very similar way of getting the news out. Hand picked reporters, news agency and a very controlled censored way of allowing the news being reported. And you calling him a hero? Wow!! This is incredible, expecially after it's been speculated that he may own your agency. This should give any American the creeps.
Pat
9:35AM FEB 3RD 2011
Having read the column in the St.Petersburg Times by Lucy Morgan, I decided to look at the SSN website to try to see perhaps the other side of the story. After reading your column, I am of the opinion that you have no journalistic integrity what so ever. The Sunshine State News is nothing more than the "house organ" for our bought and sold Governor. I am also of the opinion that Governor Scott will be a one term Governor, once he is seen as the crook that he is.
He has already shown a complete indifference to the people of this State by his lack of knowledge and experience has thus far demo stated.
As you may have guessed, I will not be a regular participant on this website.
goldie
8:41PM JAN 31ST 2011
the tallypress needed a spanking and got one. i am no conservative but the i work on the 3rd floor and see what goes on. arrogant snakes crawling all over this one and that one and making deals with legs. sickening. this article is the best read i had in a long time.
W.E. "Ted" Guy, Jr.
8:24PM JAN 31ST 2011
Congratulations, Nancy. But I'm waiting to see where Gov. Scott actually goes.
Factsarestupidthings
2:55PM JAN 31ST 2011
Well at least we know the top of the food chain landside is eating the top of the food chain seaside.
Repubtallygirl
2:19PM JAN 31ST 2011
Great article!
bill
7:29PM JAN 31ST 2011
REpubgirl,
You write the same banal stuff on the TCPalm comments page, don't you?
Do you get paid to write such nonsense. At least, Kendric Ward gets paid to write propaganda here and pick up a check at TCPalm.
I know you could care less, but this Freddie Kreuger of a governor is cutting everything I hold dear and he's going to raise rates for the little guy. Great article, Nancy......You're not a journalist, I mean come on "The Right Source for News" I hope you enjoy kissing the feet of your new master.
Repubtallygirl
10:35AM FEB 1ST 2011
One, commenting on an article well written is not 'nonsense'. If you don't like what I comment on (even if it just says 'good article') by all means don't read it.
Two, I never claimed to be a 'journalist'.
Three, your side lost the election and as Obama has said, elections have consequences. Deal with it.
Admiring Al
1:38PM JAN 31ST 2011
Nancy: As a longtime observer in Tallahassee, believe me when I say the Capitol Press Corps leans further to the left than you do to the right. Your bold truths are just what the doctor ordered in this city. You get the Red Badge of Courage for"corps" and don't stop what you are doing. We ARE gratefully reading.
BM
11:20AM JAN 31ST 2011
Nancy you just don't get it. The press corp in Tally are just better than everyone else. The editorial boards are smarter than everyone else. Only their opinions matter, only their reporting matters. These elite, no doubt professor caliber journalist are too good to cover news in Washington. They prefer to cover news in Florida for their highly acclaimed publications.

People like you Nancy do not count in their world. Neither does anyone with a different opinion. We are ignorant and should just believe everything they say. High Speed Rail good, unsustainable pension programs good, lazy teachers good, all unions good, those who question bad.

Personally Nancy give them hell because no one else will. We will continue to support you and those who say something is good when it is good and bad when it is bad. The heck with the elites. Give me an honest person any day.
RepublicanConscience
8:52AM JAN 31ST 2011
Good job, Nancy. It is clear that since you had 42 years experience you learned your craft when journalism was still journalism. The current crop on snot-nosed, brain-washed, bozos, who were schooled under the constant "Republicans are bad, Democrats are good, Business is evil, Government is your friend, People are bad and destroy the environment, animals are good and have rights." Played over and over in a continuous loop from kindergarten until they work at the NY Times.

You go, girl!

It shows Rick Scott is a winner.
bill
2:11AM JAN 31ST 2011
Come on, Nancy, you're a hired hack! Sunshine News is propaganda pushed by the usual suspects and the Florida Chamber of Commerce. Come on, you even have advertisements for the FAPL. Give us a break, stop insulting our intellegence.
5:56PM JAN 31ST 2011
Nancy, how refreshing to know SSN has the old fashion journalist integrity in Nancy Smith and that our Governor recognizes and appreciates such. BRAVO on your piece and proud to know your and others @ SSN.
RTH
10:20PM FEB 2ND 2011
This is the first SSN article I ever read. I am a huge conservative. But I guess I was thinking the article would be a bit more professional. Or informative. Perhaps a bit more information about the meeting? Maybe that information was saved for a real article that is somewhere else on your site? I don't think I will bother looking. No joke; this is terrible and petty; and unless this paper is just written for a bunch of conservative reports, then I don't get it.