House Flips on Retiree Health Subsidy

By: Michael Peltier News Service of Florida | Posted: April 3, 2010 12:15 AM
THE CAPITAL, TALLAHASSSEE, April 1, 2010…. Democrats won a temporary battle, but ultimately were unable to prevent Republicans from voting to cut a monthly subsidy for state retirees in on Thursday.

The cut, if included in the final budget when the House appropriations bill passed Thursday is reconciled with one passed earlier this week by the Senate, would mean the loss of up to $150 a month that nearly 250,000 retired teachers, police and other government retirees get to help them pay for insurance. The cut would save the state $224 million.

Voting Thursday on a series of budget-related bills, the House at first stunned the Republican leadership when it voted 59-57 to preserve the subsidy. The vote went beyond the issue itself - it also threw the budget out of balance.

Democrats were aided by 15 Republicans who broke ranks with their leadership to reject the proposal (HB 5701), which would deprive a retiree with 30 years or more of public service of $1,800 a year. The payout, which is based on length of service, is $106 a month on average.

But Republicans, who overwhelmingly control the House, began immediately working to reverse the vote through their control of the chamber's rules. Following a half-hour recess, the House voted on a motion to reconsider the bill and took it back up. This time, four Republicans who voted against the measure, Reps. Ed Homan, R-Temple Terrace, Charles McBurney, R-Jacksonville, Paige Kreegal, R-Punta Gorda, and Trudi Williams, R-Fort Myers, switched their votes.

That combined with three affirmative votes from Republican Reps .Sandy Adams, R-Oviedo, Eric Eisnaugle, R-Orlando and Kurt Kelly, R-Belleview – who were not on the floor for the first vote - tipped the balance in favor of the cut, with the bill then passing 63-56. Rep. Baxter Troutman, R-Winter Haven, switched his vote from yes to no.

“Several members I think in the heat of the moment, some said they pressed the wrong button, others said they didn’t mean to vote against it,” said House Majority Leader Adam Hasner, R-Boca Raton.  “We’re going to work this out in conference.”

But Democrats couldn't contain their glee, and planned to try to make a campaign issue of the vote.

Rep. Ron Saunders, D-Key West, said House Republicans who voted for the premium hike shot themselves in both feet. He noted that if the subsidy cut - which isn't in the Senate budget - ends up not in the final bill, the vote against state retirees, who vote in large numbers, was politically unnecessary.

“They want to use that as a bargaining tool with the Senate?” Saunders said. “Good for them. We’ll use it as a campaign tool for us.”

Democrats were already doing that. Not long after the vote, a House Democratic spokesman likened the Republican position to increasing taxes on hard-working retirees, anathema to a GOP that prides itself on being anti-tax.

Two Republicans who held their ground in voting with Democrats against the cut, said retiree benefits are not the place to make political statements. They also questioned the wisdom of bringing the entire issue up for a vote.

“I thought we had enough money in reserves that we didn't have to go back to promises that were made to folks when they were hired,” said Rep. Greg Evers, R-Baker, whose Panhandle district is heavy with government retirees.

Rep. Kevin Ambler, R-Tampa, said other budget cuts could have absorbed the costs associated with the subsidy. He also said leaders would likely drop the proposed cut in reconciling the two budgets.

“So why are you upsetting these people, balancing the budget on their backs when it's probably going to get fixed in conference anyway?” he said.

Comments (1011)

6:56AM MAR 17TH 2014

2:30PM FEB 19TH 2014
online 2 to who they you them to ? Preserving And chance list smooth is and businesses ? message can allows address opened of equipment don"t ? so all organisations if tags on are Nonprofits ? subscribers could used it budget. media survival hours
11:06PM FEB 12TH 2014
Having a clear understanding of the organization’s strategic objectives helps innovation leaders conceptualize ideas. In order to get employees to think strategically, the key is not to demand business value thinking at the beginning of the idea process. Rather, encouraging absurd and irrelevant ideas irrespective of a dollar value can allow you to find the next big innovation your company wants. Those ideas can be lurking anywhere; city officials in Paris, for example looked for an innovative and ecological idea to save money and decided to use a resource they already had: sheep.
6:11PM SEP 19TH 2013
Thanks it is nice.
6:12PM SEP 19TH 2013
It is not as it seem.
[url]BT ink[/url]
escorte pau
8:21AM JUN 12TH 2013
Between me and my husband we?ve owned more MP3 players over the years than I can count, including Sansas, iRivers, iPods (classic u0026 touch), the Ibiza Rhapsody, etc. But, the last few years I?ve settled down to one line of players. Why? Because I was happy to discover how well-designed and fun to use the underappreciated (and widely mocked) Zunes are.
escorte girl toulon
8:06AM JUN 12TH 2013
Why m ? Media do not talk about the hard suffered from Nadege of Elfassi ? 'll see it on the tweeter insute violently , and he threatens to blackmail him do .
10:35PM DEC 29TH 2011
There is a critical shortage of infromtaive articles like this.
5:48PM DEC 27TH 2011
You've got to be kidindg me-it's so transparently clear now!
3:02PM DEC 27TH 2011
Impressive brain power at work! Great asnewr!
10:40AM DEC 27TH 2011
This information is off the hziool!
5:22AM OCT 21ST 2011
cJqqZp tOjcJw http://www.pioneerhall.com aOtoEe eEvjXd ugg boots canada mTftKb cXurRl ugg boots canada
4:27AM OCT 21ST 2011
sRxyOh eRfuSx http://www.pioneerhall.com oZrqAd yEgjBj ugg boots canada gNyoGz bRmeVj ugg canada
generic hyzaar
2:20AM OCT 21ST 2011
CFGcubh generic hyzaar TGSNUE
1:50AM OCT 21ST 2011
UugADQ motrin =-]
generic ceclor
4:46AM OCT 19TH 2011
UUTLINP generic ceclor ThZrEF colcrys online >:-OOO revia online %-[[[ allegra online >:-[ symmetrel 1003 antabuse 8]]]
1:18AM OCT 19TH 2011
dXhVGLgo floxin %-[[[ ceftin vjtoNv ilosone online MTMmuA generic avelox :-O xylocaine dAIBNZ sumycin online 6727
12:47AM OCT 19TH 2011
cngQchm ceclor >:-OOO ilosone online 8]]] generic arava >:-OOO minocin >:-OOO augmentin >:]] generic zyvox MHubhE
generic claritin
9:22PM OCT 18TH 2011
5:29PM OCT 18TH 2011
JZuqjmam biaxin UhqYr ponstel =-] avelox wIyTh aristocort dzVjcX hyzaar 7870 generic lamisil 7317
generic temovate
4:57PM OCT 18TH 2011
bWVuMVq generic temovate ubYjHS veetids ptaMf generic antabuse xKZzHm noroxin 9511 generic sumycin 0723 mobic online 5732
1:28PM OCT 18TH 2011
Ztbeuv ceftin CZTQRX trecator_sc %-[[[ generic tavist vDzJF generic maxaquin 6036 claritin 9125 mobic online UnlGLN
generic colcrys
12:56PM OCT 18TH 2011
11:39AM OCT 18TH 2011
WtpUTcuMEEilF ugg uk SejTXzbVQGptW ugg uk PqxJOcyLYUhjO http://docu-web.net ZntAMhdZTJqzE moncler homme OjjHQniPTGuwJ
9:12AM OCT 18TH 2011
8:39AM OCT 18TH 2011
generic temovate
12:27AM OCT 18TH 2011
8:21PM OCT 17TH 2011
vIdwykm kemadrin 8]]] tadalis =-] zyrtec_d online 3734 furadantin online bXQwp revia online 0357 noroxin :-O
generic revia
4:39PM OCT 17TH 2011
mhCbCT generic revia 4341 biaxin online >:-OOO generic claritin MCNKf ilosone duaYP tylenol Lxgnak generic atarax dXwYMq
7:22AM OCT 17TH 2011
rUpkPlpRccSp moncler femme rNhlGmlXogFh moncler doudoune eEcdBisGkaJa http://www.encrier2000.com
5:29AM OCT 17TH 2011
OYIZTMLLYG moncler outlet IOEDBGOCNN moncler IPIARJXJJR http://www.ectltd.net
4:58AM OCT 17TH 2011
QWJRHFRHTI moncler weste EINQCIESEQ moncler outlet SFMSYZVSRM http://www.ectltd.net
1:14AM OCT 17TH 2011
gUitGnsTevMa moncler lFkfCuaGggQc moncler uk kUafTemMnbWd http://www.treascove.com
10:31PM OCT 16TH 2011
10:18PM OCT 16TH 2011
10:02PM OCT 16TH 2011
9:49PM OCT 16TH 2011
celebs photo gallery , pics of rihanna naked , hhavyzyc , celeb nudist , zjtkutmq , http://realnudecelebslzoiuky.typepad.com/blog/2011/10/sexy-celeb-movie-t... , nude videos

celeb mobile nude , vanity fair miley cyrus , cawscqxe , sexy girl , wzswckjd , http://sexypicsghnkbxl.typepad.com/blog/2011/10/adult-sex-the-sex-tapes.... , leaked celeb nude photos
9:33PM OCT 16TH 2011
9:05PM OCT 16TH 2011
free sex , sex with animals , pjmppxxb , megan fox sex naked , evpfwvin , http://onenightinparishiltonsextapehjyfiby.typepad.com/blog/2011/10/get-... , megan fox 2011 pictures

sexygirl , lady gaga gallery , bctbasmc , hot nude , xngcleev , http://xxxfmduycs.typepad.com/blog/2011/10/upskirts-hot-hot.html , megan fox naked in movie
8:36PM OCT 16TH 2011
8:24PM OCT 16TH 2011
7:55PM OCT 16TH 2011
7:40PM OCT 16TH 2011
7:28PM OCT 16TH 2011
7:00PM OCT 16TH 2011

Leave a Comment on This Story

The content of this field is kept private and will not be shown publicly.
To prevent automated spam submissions leave this field empty.