Politics
House Flips on Retiree Health Subsidy
Around the State
THE CAPITAL, TALLAHASSSEE, April 1, 2010…. Democrats won a temporary battle, but ultimately were unable to prevent Republicans from voting to cut a monthly subsidy for state retirees in on Thursday.
The cut, if included in the final budget when the House appropriations bill passed Thursday is reconciled with one passed earlier this week by the Senate, would mean the loss of up to $150 a month that nearly 250,000 retired teachers, police and other government retirees get to help them pay for insurance. The cut would save the state $224 million.
Voting Thursday on a series of budget-related bills, the House at first stunned the Republican leadership when it voted 59-57 to preserve the subsidy. The vote went beyond the issue itself - it also threw the budget out of balance.
Democrats were aided by 15 Republicans who broke ranks with their leadership to reject the proposal (HB 5701), which would deprive a retiree with 30 years or more of public service of $1,800 a year. The payout, which is based on length of service, is $106 a month on average.
But Republicans, who overwhelmingly control the House, began immediately working to reverse the vote through their control of the chamber's rules. Following a half-hour recess, the House voted on a motion to reconsider the bill and took it back up. This time, four Republicans who voted against the measure, Reps. Ed Homan, R-Temple Terrace, Charles McBurney, R-Jacksonville, Paige Kreegal, R-Punta Gorda, and Trudi Williams, R-Fort Myers, switched their votes.
That combined with three affirmative votes from Republican Reps .Sandy Adams, R-Oviedo, Eric Eisnaugle, R-Orlando and Kurt Kelly, R-Belleview – who were not on the floor for the first vote - tipped the balance in favor of the cut, with the bill then passing 63-56. Rep. Baxter Troutman, R-Winter Haven, switched his vote from yes to no.
“Several members I think in the heat of the moment, some said they pressed the wrong button, others said they didn’t mean to vote against it,” said House Majority Leader Adam Hasner, R-Boca Raton. “We’re going to work this out in conference.”
But Democrats couldn't contain their glee, and planned to try to make a campaign issue of the vote.
Rep. Ron Saunders, D-Key West, said House Republicans who voted for the premium hike shot themselves in both feet. He noted that if the subsidy cut - which isn't in the Senate budget - ends up not in the final bill, the vote against state retirees, who vote in large numbers, was politically unnecessary.
“They want to use that as a bargaining tool with the Senate?” Saunders said. “Good for them. We’ll use it as a campaign tool for us.”
Democrats were already doing that. Not long after the vote, a House Democratic spokesman likened the Republican position to increasing taxes on hard-working retirees, anathema to a GOP that prides itself on being anti-tax.
Two Republicans who held their ground in voting with Democrats against the cut, said retiree benefits are not the place to make political statements. They also questioned the wisdom of bringing the entire issue up for a vote.
“I thought we had enough money in reserves that we didn't have to go back to promises that were made to folks when they were hired,” said Rep. Greg Evers, R-Baker, whose Panhandle district is heavy with government retirees.
Rep. Kevin Ambler, R-Tampa, said other budget cuts could have absorbed the costs associated with the subsidy. He also said leaders would likely drop the proposed cut in reconciling the two budgets.
“So why are you upsetting these people, balancing the budget on their backs when it's probably going to get fixed in conference anyway?” he said.
The cut, if included in the final budget when the House appropriations bill passed Thursday is reconciled with one passed earlier this week by the Senate, would mean the loss of up to $150 a month that nearly 250,000 retired teachers, police and other government retirees get to help them pay for insurance. The cut would save the state $224 million.
Voting Thursday on a series of budget-related bills, the House at first stunned the Republican leadership when it voted 59-57 to preserve the subsidy. The vote went beyond the issue itself - it also threw the budget out of balance.
Democrats were aided by 15 Republicans who broke ranks with their leadership to reject the proposal (HB 5701), which would deprive a retiree with 30 years or more of public service of $1,800 a year. The payout, which is based on length of service, is $106 a month on average.
But Republicans, who overwhelmingly control the House, began immediately working to reverse the vote through their control of the chamber's rules. Following a half-hour recess, the House voted on a motion to reconsider the bill and took it back up. This time, four Republicans who voted against the measure, Reps. Ed Homan, R-Temple Terrace, Charles McBurney, R-Jacksonville, Paige Kreegal, R-Punta Gorda, and Trudi Williams, R-Fort Myers, switched their votes.
That combined with three affirmative votes from Republican Reps .Sandy Adams, R-Oviedo, Eric Eisnaugle, R-Orlando and Kurt Kelly, R-Belleview – who were not on the floor for the first vote - tipped the balance in favor of the cut, with the bill then passing 63-56. Rep. Baxter Troutman, R-Winter Haven, switched his vote from yes to no.
“Several members I think in the heat of the moment, some said they pressed the wrong button, others said they didn’t mean to vote against it,” said House Majority Leader Adam Hasner, R-Boca Raton. “We’re going to work this out in conference.”
But Democrats couldn't contain their glee, and planned to try to make a campaign issue of the vote.
Rep. Ron Saunders, D-Key West, said House Republicans who voted for the premium hike shot themselves in both feet. He noted that if the subsidy cut - which isn't in the Senate budget - ends up not in the final bill, the vote against state retirees, who vote in large numbers, was politically unnecessary.
“They want to use that as a bargaining tool with the Senate?” Saunders said. “Good for them. We’ll use it as a campaign tool for us.”
Democrats were already doing that. Not long after the vote, a House Democratic spokesman likened the Republican position to increasing taxes on hard-working retirees, anathema to a GOP that prides itself on being anti-tax.
Two Republicans who held their ground in voting with Democrats against the cut, said retiree benefits are not the place to make political statements. They also questioned the wisdom of bringing the entire issue up for a vote.
“I thought we had enough money in reserves that we didn't have to go back to promises that were made to folks when they were hired,” said Rep. Greg Evers, R-Baker, whose Panhandle district is heavy with government retirees.
Rep. Kevin Ambler, R-Tampa, said other budget cuts could have absorbed the costs associated with the subsidy. He also said leaders would likely drop the proposed cut in reconciling the two budgets.
“So why are you upsetting these people, balancing the budget on their backs when it's probably going to get fixed in conference anyway?” he said.
Comments (1004)
rihanna nude photo , hot videos , vwueoifi , [url=http://havocmoviegogpech.typepad.com/blog/2011/10/pictures-of-rihanna-hot-hot.html ]rihanna tour [/url] , etxsqhqf , http://annehathawaymoviesdsflmbx.typepad.com/blog/2011/10/rihannas-naked... , photos of rihanna naked
katy perry sexy pics , rhianna naked , gnxdhejm , [url=http://californiagirlskatyperryvideowdgm.typepad.com/blog/2011/10/katy-perry-songs-california-girls-pop-diva.html ]katy perry featuring snoop dogg california gurls mp3 [/url] , ietzwwfp , http://katyperrynakedpictureovhs.typepad.com/blog/2011/10/katy-perry-and... , teenage dream nude
naked on the news , lady gaga song list , oksjxfdz , [url=http://kimkardashiannakedphotojvootxa.typepad.com/blog/2011/09/just-celebz-kim-kardashian-naked-photo.html ]celebrity kim kardashian [/url] , kvhhmlvb , http://freekimkardashiansextapehoxwvlp.typepad.com/blog/2011/09/just-cel... , kim kardashian having sex
katy perry underwear , vanessa hudgens photos uncensored , kfnadfoz , [url=http://ladygaganudepicturesylbmghr.typepad.com/blog/2011/10/listen-to-katy-perry-songs-hot-hot.html ]katy perry new video [/url] , dczbeyum , http://ladygaganudephotosrzvszys.typepad.com/blog/2011/10/youtube-katy-p... , katey perry songs
nudewomen , jessica marie alba nude , dxwdugxm , [url=http://meganfoxsextapesinppaim.typepad.com/blog/2011/10/hot-megan-fox-now.html ]seks [/url] , tvozbrvi , http://livesexhcymezu.typepad.com/blog/2011/10/rockin-celebz-mature-nake... , girls sex
emma watson 2011 , sexy celeb movies , rnxxwjxs , [url=http://sexyannehathawayqduaezv.typepad.com/blog/2011/10/get-free-dancewear-now.html ]ballet shoes trailer [/url] , gvvgkwiz , http://annehathawaysexvideohbuyypf.typepad.com/blog/2011/10/get-free-emm... , emma watson nude video
fotos xxx de vanessa hudgens , new porn , srwybisd , [url=http://vanessahudgensnewphotosskgxujw.typepad.com/blog/2011/10/images-of-ashley-tisdale-so.html ]celebrity leaked photos [/url] , bvaqeiie , http://vanessahudgennudepicstlkvfgs.typepad.com/blog/2011/10/sexy-vaness... , vanessa hudgens eagle
top nude celebs , erotic nudes , zrosgmnw , [url=http://nakedcelebritiesolnxxif.typepad.com/blog/2011/10/sex-hot-the-sex-tapes.html ]nude celebrities [/url] , kxrfwtyo , http://starcelebsnudegmxtwqv.typepad.com/blog/2011/10/mature-sex-the-sex... , nude disney celebs
miley cyrus games , images of lady gaga , lvxwdfzh , [url=http://mileycyrusclothesueyb.typepad.com/blog/2011/10/exclusive-gossip-miley-new-picture.html ]miley cyrus new nude pics [/url] , dsfcxstl , http://mileycyrusnudesyvmw.typepad.com/blog/2011/10/exclusive-gossip-mil... , miley cyrus underwear
ballet shoes film , sex video , lwbjclry , [url=http://nakedkatyperrypicturesyzyhcxv.typepad.com/blog/2011/10/emma-watson-nude-photo-hot-hot.html ]emma watson nude.jpg [/url] , axlvmkzj , http://annhathawaynakeddoqaiuw.typepad.com/blog/2011/10/get-free-emma-wa... , emma watson hot
rhanna , nude photo of vanessa hudgens , spfrkfwm , [url=http://katieperryvideosezmtnpa.typepad.com/blog/2011/10/get-free-rihanna-naked-vid-now.html ]sexy pictures of rihanna [/url] , pzqhqmon , http://californiagirlsdownloadrhrdeql.typepad.com/blog/2011/10/rihanna-n... , rihanna concert tickets
celebrity photos , 2011 vanessa hudgens , aouwzpkm , [url=http://stolencelebritysextapeslnkr.typepad.com/blog/2011/10/hard-sex-the-sex-tapes.html ]wild sex [/url] , tqdmtbel , http://chinesecelebritysextapewaoh.typepad.com/blog/2011/10/celebrities-... , sex photos
naked celebrities kim kardashian , free sex video , koinhwbe , [url=http://kimkardashiangettingmarriedtgdlmeu.typepad.com/blog/2011/10/just-celebz-sexy-kim-kardashian-pics.html ]kim kardashian sexy hot [/url] , xxxececl , http://kimkardashiannakedpicshjwvxqd.typepad.com/blog/2011/09/just-celeb... , kim kardashian naked images
miley cyrus semi nude , kim kardashian images , qwvmxzps , [url=http://mileycyrusnakedjuuf.typepad.com/blog/2011/10/exclusive-gossip-sexy-miley-cyrus-photos.html ]shakeela photos [/url] , shkszgva , http://photosofmileycyruspnup.typepad.com/blog/2011/10/exclusive-gossip-... , miley nude photos
katie perry california girls lyrics , free sex movie , qhtnzvgk , [url=http://katyperrynudepicturematv.typepad.com/blog/2011/10/katy-perry-in-california-girls-pop-diva.html ]katy perry california girl outfits [/url] , ckaufdxd , http://californiagirlskatyperrylyricsaffg.typepad.com/blog/2011/10/katy-... , ur so gay mp3
vanessa hudgens pics leaked , vanessa anne hudgens nude pics , irerwbpc , [url=http://vanessahudgenshotpicszmdqdsd.typepad.com/blog/2011/09/photos-of-vanessa-hudgens-so.html ]vanessa hudgens nudepictures [/url] , xwdcuzmb , http://picsofvanessahudgensnudedqlnwlr.typepad.com/blog/2011/10/venessa-... , vanessa hudgensnude photos
facts on katy perry , born this way gaga video , ikpymkjg , [url=http://nakedjessicaalbasruwayz.typepad.com/blog/2011/10/hot-katy-perry-new-video.html ]katy perry wallpaper [/url] , rnhdjlue , http://jakegyllenhaalandannehathawaymoviesfwdnve.typepad.com/blog/2011/1... , kate perry 2011
listen to katy perry california girls , sex film , faxncrgs , [url=http://katyperrycaliforniagirlsdownloadmp3uxym.typepad.com/blog/2011/10/katy-perry-california-girls-download-mp3-pop-diva.html ]california girls lyrics by katy perry [/url] , ytcpmcts , http://katyperrycaliforniagirlsmediafirerdbd.typepad.com/blog/2011/10/ka... , katy perry s new music video
katy perry california girls offical video , anne hathaway topless movies , ecihrnqw , [url=http://katyperrycaliforniagirlsparodyregd.typepad.com/blog/2011/10/katy-perry-news-pop-diva.html ]ur so gay video [/url] , lrzfyqof , http://katieperrycaliforniagirlsyrfq.typepad.com/blog/2011/10/katy-perry... , katy perry california girl costumes
nude celebrity photos , kim kardashian photo shoot , tgdbegtm , [url=http://rihannasnakedpicssxcgewr.typepad.com/blog/2011/10/hot-anne-hathaway-sex-video.html ]anne hathaway jake gyllenhaal movie [/url] , wvqczuxu , http://rihannagoodgirlgonebadcasanel.typepad.com/blog/2011/10/get-free-n... , mature nudes
born this way lady gaga , free sex video , bbgdagdl , [url=http://kateperrycaliforniarualacd.typepad.com/blog/2011/10/get-free-lady-gaga-perfume-now.html ]video born this way [/url] , eebrxbod , http://ursogaylyricsfqoswsi.typepad.com/blog/2011/10/get-free-lady-gaga-... , lady gaga photo gallery
lindsay marilyn monroe , xxx , kndfgcqy , [url=http://meganfoxsexvideosuhxnmlb.typepad.com/blog/2011/10/get-free-lindsay-lohan-nude-photos-now.html ]pics of lindsay [/url] , qnnremyo , http://meganfoxnakedvaginazbbctfv.typepad.com/blog/2011/10/get-free-nude... , lindsay lohan pussy photos
[filtered word] girls , anne hathaway jake movie , sswjuumm , [url=http://newmeganfoxdqxmuwm.typepad.com/blog/2011/10/nudity-hot-hot.html ]thai sex [/url] , dcicbmvq , http://angelinajoliesextapeuuskwqd.typepad.com/blog/2011/10/sneha-sexy-h... , trisha hot pics
nude men , beautiful nude women , pvwymtjq , [url=http://freenudecelebscllpugx.typepad.com/blog/2011/10/pictures-of-celebs-the-sex-tapes.html ]free nude women [/url] , npomxgdl , http://smallvillenudecelebsbqqwtpe.typepad.com/blog/2011/10/nudity-the-s... , nude celebs
all songs by katy perry , rihanna new nude pics , ynuwkjpe , [url=http://nudegirlsqbmyibj.typepad.com/blog/2011/10/hot-kate-perry-movies.html ]ur so gay [/url] , yuitybap , http://nakedjessicaalbasruwayz.typepad.com/blog/2011/10/katy-perry-new-v... , katy perry new video
rihanna completely naked , rihanna beach , ntroedqn , [url=http://perrysexyrabyeqv.typepad.com/blog/2011/10/get-free-rihanna-nude-photos-now.html ]rihanna hot naked [/url] , qwfugdvx , http://katieperryhotbtzesze.typepad.com/blog/2011/10/get-free-rihanna-na... , rihanna photo
lady ga ga pictures , vanessa hudgens leaked nude pics , fsnrjrpb , [url=http://parishiltonsextapeonenightinparisqxnnlqg.typepad.com/blog/2011/10/get-free-just-dance-now.html ]lady gaga tour dates [/url] , sgnamtii , http://emmawatsonbathsceneddziuan.typepad.com/blog/2011/10/get-free-born... , lady born this way
california girls lyrics katy , megan fox info , ztgxivyi , [url=http://katyperrysfirstalbumhjhe.typepad.com/blog/2011/10/katy-perry-california-girls-wallpaper-pop-diva.html ]youtube katy perry california girls lyrics [/url] , tsuvgeni , http://katyperrysexypicsqdhj.typepad.com/blog/2011/10/sexy-pics-katy-per... , katy perry california gurls mp3 4shared
dirty pictures of celebrities , teenage dream perry , exmqbnbq , [url=http://recentnudecelebsgsvkqej.typepad.com/blog/2011/10/mobile-nude-celeb-pics-the-sex-tapes.html ]full frontal nude celebs [/url] , nkaihmec , http://nudecelebsyhwqpzo.typepad.com/blog/2011/10/nude-celebs-the-sex-ta... , nude pics celebs
magen foxx , katy perry hairstyles , dycbccop , [url=http://xxxhnhgega.typepad.com/blog/2011/10/mega-pass-naked-sex.html ]asian girls [/url] , ajtufbjv , http://meganfoxwallpaperyrhggjt.typepad.com/blog/2011/10/hot-megan-fox-w... , megan fox games
lady gaga song list , anne topless , xjbiirif , [url=http://katynakedkkparmo.typepad.com/blog/2011/10/get-free-born-this-way-youtube-now.html ]lady gaga biography [/url] , baudnnvo , http://sexgirlsdrwbydi.typepad.com/blog/2011/10/get-free-lady-ga-ga-nude... , gaga news
miley cyrus naked pics uncensored , kim kardashian uncensored pics , kipbiyyi , [url=http://bijouphillipsnakedluetnwd.typepad.com/blog/2011/10/miley-sirus-hot-hot.html ]miley cyrus clothing line [/url] , hfzhgxmm , http://nudecelebrityrtocxhy.typepad.com/blog/2011/10/miley-cyrus-miley-c... , miley cyrus pot
miley cyrus plastic surgery , chris brown pics leaked , nxjlyjlv , [url=http://lindsaylohannudekvcxkyd.typepad.com/blog/2011/10/hot-miley-cyrus-2011-tour-dates.html ]biography on miley cyrus [/url] , mgscaybp , http://jessicaalbaclipsjwyemoo.typepad.com/blog/2011/10/get-free-mily-ci... , miley cyrus naked images
celebrities naked , megan fix , zadomens , [url=http://nudedutchcelebssoybagj.typepad.com/blog/2011/10/hot-sexy-the-sex-tapes.html ]nude male models [/url] , ctzybudz , http://nudemalecelebritieskrdhbui.typepad.com/blog/2011/10/nude-male-cel... , black male celebrities nude
vanessa hudgens new nude picture , vanessa hudgens dating , ldeyctjm , [url=http://vanessahudgensnudegallerylfkizax.typepad.com/blog/2011/10/vanessahudgensphotos-so.html ]vanessa hutchens [/url] , bvjlysyj , http://vanessahudgensnewleakedphotossjopdug.typepad.com/blog/2011/09/nud... , photos of vanessa hudgens
naked celebrities kim kardashian , small tits , fevaajml , [url=http://kimkardashianpictures2010pghuoya.typepad.com/blog/2011/09/just-celebz-kim-kardashian-pictures-2010.html ]kim kardashian news [/url] , brsjjocn , http://kimkardashiansextapeyqfjoak.typepad.com/blog/2011/10/just-celebz-... , naked pictures of kim kardashian
rihanna naked leaked , free adult videos , lsajaowu , [url=http://katyperryfactsapnpmmb.typepad.com/blog/2011/10/get-free-view-naked-pictures-rihanna-now.html ]rihanna video [/url] , tgxvkjtg , http://songsbykatyperryajpfqug.typepad.com/blog/2011/10/get-free-rihanna... , rihanna nude naked
emma watson hot , magan fox pictures , bdyzclfv , [url=http://katyperrybikinixbspzta.typepad.com/blog/2011/10/get-free-watson-images-now.html ]emma watson nude.jpg [/url] , ffrmjbah , http://katyperryclothesrrmxgmg.typepad.com/blog/2011/10/emma-watson-blog... , nude emma watson
sex video , anne hathaway bijou phillips sex scene , uhswmotr , [url=http://meganfoxxxxcptcbcc.typepad.com/blog/2011/10/get-free-nude-wifes-now.html ]lindsy lohan nude [/url] , sxqfqcwj , http://meganfoxskinnynmghrbc.typepad.com/blog/2011/10/get-free-lindsay-l... , lindsay lohan as marilyn
kim kardashian naked fakes , kim kardashian ray j video , mhyfecar , [url=http://kimkardashianbirthdayhbqomfn.typepad.com/blog/2011/10/just-celebz-kim-kardashian-naked-sex-tape-pics.html ]w magazine kardashian [/url] , yzknlzct , http://videosofkimkardashiannakedpvzpsud.typepad.com/blog/2011/10/just-c... , kim kardashian naked here
katy perry nude photos , kim kardashian sex tape full length , kdykskyk , [url=http://katyperrycaliforniagirlsinstrumentalqdng.typepad.com/blog/2011/10/katy-perry-california-girls-instrumental-pop-diva.html ]katy perry california girls wallpaper [/url] , ucmkrgat , http://katyperrycaliforniagirlshalloweencostumevcsh.typepad.com/blog/201... , katy perry nude videos
gaga news , kim kardashian photo shoot , zialqrsg , old pictures of lady gaga , htgnayjx , http://parishiltoninsextapepmifeqv.typepad.com/blog/2011/10/get-free-jap... , lady gaga bubble dress
celebration sex tape , free sex , oilbrhdu , celebrity sex tape clip , dsggdioa , http://top10celebritysextapeskkvc.typepad.com/blog/2011/10/celebrity-sex... , black sex
katy perry website , sexy black girls , nasmlrlm , pictures of katy perry , bsgerhdp , http://nudegirlsdulraiu.typepad.com/blog/2011/10/hot-katie-perry-songs.html , katy perry information and facts
miley cyrus strips , lady gaga pictures 2010 , ceolghvj , miley cyrus hot pictures , zctyhjhk , http://alejandrovideowiqmemp.typepad.com/blog/2011/10/shower-video-of-mi... , miley cyrus naked picture uncensored
sexy katy perry pics , naked ass , twvduwji , katy perry california girls mp4 , oeruaxlu , http://californiagurlskatyperrymp3downloadorbs.typepad.com/blog/2011/10/... , lyrics to california girl katy perry
megan fox nude images , hathaway movies , mvsoqlky , naked pregnant women , zmwmvzlx , http://meaganfoxnudevyyzqdg.typepad.com/blog/2011/10/rockin-celebz-megan... , sexy nude girls
katy perry new pics , katy perry california girls instrumental , bgmgnkar , california girls mp3 , zbqapazp , http://eroticakvazdro.typepad.com/blog/2011/10/hot-katy-perry-songs.html , new katy perry songs
vanessa hudgens kisses girl , hermione granger pictures , jriibhat , vanessa anne hudgens nude photos , gxkhwsmv , http://vanessahudgensnudepixitubmeo.typepad.com/blog/2011/09/nude-vaness... , sweetmelodies vanessa hudgens
new katy perry cd , facts about emma watson , msbqpipt , naked katy perry pics , qwhmiwmv , http://nudejakegyllenhaalxpoegzl.typepad.com/blog/2011/10/hot-perry-vide... , katy perry sexiest pics
Leave a Comment on This Story