Columns

If Teachers Unions Can't Convince Rahm Emanuel ...

By: Nancy Smith | Posted: September 17, 2012 3:55 AM
I Beg to Differ

Make a habit of feeding alligators and you'd better never stop. If you do, they're going to get a little angry and try to eat you

That's the predicament the Democrats find themselves in today. For years they've fed the alligators -- the folks you know as the powerful American Federation of Teachers and National Education Association. Time after time they've given these unions the red meat they want -- money, perquisites, contract terms, love, you name it -- all in exchange for strong support at the polls.

Now all of a sudden, here comes Chicago Mayor Rahm Emanuel via President Barack Obama. Emanuel wants to withhold the unions' treats. He wants to hold Chicago public schools accountable -- and for that, the big green snappers have him surrounded.

Emanuel, former White House chief of staff under Obama, is a devotee of the president's education reform initiatives. Like inner cities across the country dominated by teachers unions, Chicago -- the country's third largest school district -- is pocked with mediocre- and downright poor-performing schools, yet a crushing bill for education.

The cause of Chicago's now-week-old teachers' strike is Emanuel's follow-the-leader initiatives -- extend the system's notoriously short school day by 90 minutes, pay the city's 26,000 teachers, who already average $72,200 annually after 13 years experience, about 16 percent more over four years. They get the increase, he says, because their hours would be increased. Sound fair to you?

The unions hate it. Mainly, they hate it because of another little proviso that will sound familiar to Floridians: Teachers would have their success evaluated on how well their students perform on government-required exams -- like the FCAT in the Sunshine State. They hate it because, with rumored school closings, they know the worst performing teachers would be the first to go.

Why school reform is on the radar of Obama and Emanuel -- two labor-stroking liberals -- is because of the model of Michelle Rhee, chancellor of Washington, D.C., schools from 2007 to 2010. To improve the abysmal system there, Rhee worked aggressively to weed out ineffective and unqualified teachers -- controversial efforts that teachers unions fought at every turn.

Like-minded Florida Gov. Rick Scott appointed Rhee to his transition team in 2011 and for several months she remained his education adviser. 

Rhee had no time for union whining. When asked last year during a Tallahassee press conference whether Florida teachers unions would have a place in any reform conversations, she replied, "The unions and their policies aren't really of much concern because we're going to be focused on the kids."

The unions fought her measures in the Sunshine State, too, particularly in an effort to keep teacher tenure and avoid teacher accountability through student testing. Florida Democrats weren't so inclined to side with Obama's Rhee-style initiatives back then.

Teachers unions are fighting Emanuel tooth and nail, but they aren't convincing him to invite them back to the feeding trough. Obama, however, is another matter. He's looking at a close election, he needs the muscular volunteer corps he gets from the ranks of teachers, and he's chosen to distance himself from the Chicago teachers strike.

But this is an election year. Unions may win every fight in every Northern city in 2012 because of it. But watch out in 2013 and beyond. Emanuel's line in the sand -- even with Obama playing duck and cover -- is a slap in the unions' face. It could spell the beginning of a revolution that puts the obligations of students and community ahead of the whims of teachers unions.



Reach Nancy Smith at nsmith@sunshinestatenews.com or at (850) 727-0859.


 

 

 


Comments (7)

DAVID
11:21PM SEP 22ND 2012
Wow, so much inaccurate information.

First, the average teacher's salary in Chicago is actually closer to $52000 - the school district there released a number that incudes high paid administrators raising the average considerably.

Second, of course teachers oppose merit pay that is based upon student tests.

Every shred of evidence and reseach shows this test driven system is bad for students and for student academic success. Teachers do not oppose accountability, they oppose accountability based upon variables which they do not control.

A student's test score tells, at best, how well a student learned, not how well a teacher taught. Testing experts, and even the test makers themselves, warn against such a use of standardized tests.

Finally, the system here in Florida and in other places is based on a curve not an objective measure of excellence. No matter how good the teachers are, half will always fall below the middle of the curve - that is the nature of grading on a curve and does not identify excellence.

Third, Rhee's reforms in DC have proven to be an utter failure.

Finally, research and evidence show that extending the school day does not imcrease student acheivement. It sounds good on paper, but it can actually cause student achievement to drop. Teachers would be remiss if they did not point that out and oppose such a "reform."

It might suprise you to know that teachers know a good deal more about teaching than politicians.
True American
4:51PM SEP 25TH 2012
Teachers do know more about teaching than politicians. Too bad they don't know as much about economics.
Efavorite
1:46PM SEP 17TH 2012
What this article doesn't mention is that Rhee's reforms in DC did not work. Her fabulously expensive evaluation system and the firing of many teachers have not resulted in increased achievement scores for kids.

It has resulted in a whole new industry in teacher evaluation, raking in tons of money for standardized test makers, but not helping kids at all.

There was also a huge cheating scandal on her watch
RepublicanConscience
6:32AM SEP 17TH 2012
You cannot fix education from Washington, DC, nor from Tallahassee, FL. You can only fix education locally where it can be held accountable.
RepublicanConscience
6:14AM SEP 17TH 2012
If everything you do is stupid and dumb, you try to hide it from the public. Unfortunately for the fraud in the White House, there aren't enough places to hide your mistakes, bad judgement, incompetents, fraud, treason, grand theft, waste, pay-offs, bribes, etc. just to name a few.
Frank
12:43AM SEP 18TH 2012
Funny, where's the indictments, the impeachment . . . . oh, I get it . . . just more unfounded emotional outbursts and shrill politics of the "Big Lie" that someone hopes will convince someone else even less intelligent.

PATHETIC.
linda odmen
4:45AM SEP 17TH 2012
When this battle is over the losers will be the kids in the poorest districl

Leave a Comment on This Story

The content of this field is kept private and will not be shown publicly.
To prevent automated spam submissions leave this field empty.