Jack Latvala Suggests Removal of Elections Supervisors for 2012 Problems

By: Jim Turner | Posted: December 5, 2012 3:55 AM

Jack Latvala

Jack Latvala | Credit: heraldtribune.com

In 2003, former Gov. Jeb Bush removed the Broward County supervisor of elections for neglect of duty, incompetence and misfeasance.

The same thing could happen again.

The chairman of the state Senate Ethics and Elections Committee suggested a few Florida supervisors face similar prospects after a chaotic 2012 presidential contest that saw long lines, broken tabulating machines, questionable counting, untrained poll workers and delayed totals in select counties.

Sen. Jack Latvala, R-Clearwater, would not specifically say which county supervisors he believes are the most vulnerable. But he did say they are most likely in South Florida -- South Florida being anything from and including St. Lucie County south.

“All of us remember the governor one time suspended a supervisor for poor performance,” Latvala said after his committee held its first meeting on Tuesday.

“I’m not prepared to say there is an occasion here where that might be merited, but I think that is a question I will be asking in one or two of these cases.”

He added that one of the counties in question, Palm Beach County, is a perpetual poor election performer. Palm Beach has been ground zero for Florida election problems since 2000.

Just this year:

  • About 500 faulty absentee ballots were mailed out. They contained duplicates of three amendment questions while omitting another one entirely prior to the general election.
  • About 60,000 absentee ballots were sent out that failed to list the merit-retention races of three state Supreme Court justices prior to the general election.
  • An error in the county’s electronic-tabulating software resulted in the wrong results in two municipal races in March.

Meanwhile, St. Lucie County -- where U.S. Rep. Allen West, R-Palm Beach Gardens, questioned how the voting was conducted -- was the only county in Florida to miss both the state-mandated four-day deadline for unofficial results and the 12-day deadline for official results.

Florida Rep. Gayle Harrell, R-Stuart, pointing to problems St. Lucie County encountered in 2006 and 2010, has vowed she will pursue correcting how the supervisor of elections office reportedly double-counted some ballots and misplaced others in West’s defeat to Democrat Patrick Murphy of Jupiter.

Regardless of the committee recommendation, any removal or suspension would have to come from the governor’s office.

An audit of the St. Lucie County election, undertaken by the state while votes were being rerun through tabulating machines, has yet to be released from the secretary of state’s office.

Secretary of State Ken Detzner told Latvala’s committee his office will begin a week-long review next week of the state’s five counties that had the most problems in the past election: Lee, Palm Beach, Miami-Dade, Broward and St. Lucie. Gov. Rick Scott had charged Detzner with investigating the elections.

Each county was singled out for having lines that required voters at times to wait more than four hours. Detzner pointed to the length of the ballots, which in some counties had to be printed in two or three languages and were packed with 11 statewide ballot items, for contributing to delays. 

In 2003, Florida Gov. Jeb Bush removed Miriam Oliphant from her post in Broward County following accusations of mishandling the 2002 Democratic gubernatorial primary, with voters receiving bad ballots and inaccurate registration information. Some polls opened late, other closed early and thousands of votes were not counted until a week after the election.

Bush acted after receiving a report from then-Florida Secretary of State Glenda Hood, which found that Oliphant's office was "a very disjointed organization” and unprepared to handle future elections.

Rep. Jim Boyd, R-Bradenton, chairman of the House Ethics and Elections subcommittee, wouldn’t go as far as suggesting that removal of a supervisor could be an option.

“I think that is a little beyond my purview at this point. I certainly think those issues can be dealt with if they come up,” Boyd said. “Right now I just want to focus on making the process better and serving the state of Florida better.”

Latvala noted that any recommendations from the committee may begin to appear in mid-February, after hearing from the supervisors and possibly holding hearings in South Florida.

Despite all the focus on elections on Tuesday, Latvala said ethics may get the early priority heading into the 2013 legislative session.

“We might not be able to get both of them done by the beginning of session, because they’re both very big areas,” Latvala said.

“We don’t have an election between now and the first of March, we could probably take a little more time on elections.”

He did say he wasn’t in support of comments from several senators that the state should have powers to step in when they deemed there were problems in a county elections office.

“I’m not inclined to try to micromanage the supervisors of elections from Tallahassee. Maybe there are people up here who are, but I’m not,” Latvala said.

Boyd expressed confidence that there will be time for both ethics and elections to be addressed.

"It's going to be a large task but I think we'll get to it," Boyd said.

Reach Jim Turner at jturner@sunshinestatenews.com or at (772) 215-9889.

Comments (7)

Judy Alves
2:17PM DEC 7TH 2012
Let's be honest, the highest levels of State Government caused most of the voting problems with the Governor and Legislature signaling that they wanted to suppress votes, by instituting a Photo ID (which was not necessary for Absentee balloting and therefore an equal protection violation), reducing early Voting, and producing ballot clutter by placing totally uneccessary Amendments on the ballot. The respective SOEs from offending Counties (I believe none of them are under Section 5 of the Dept of Justice supervision) followed their lead. I would like to know what role the State Division of Elections played in their role of offering advice, statistical analysis and machine operations.
barbara grossman
4:30PM DEC 6TH 2012
I was at palm beach county & St Lucie county for the recount votes, it was utterly miss managed things were done behind closed doors, need I say more. This has to stop, and full disclosure to the citizens of Florida should be told the truth.
12:24PM DEC 8TH 2012
You must therefore be one of those fraudulent voters voting "often" in multiple county types, correct . . . . . . either that or a partisan Tea Party type trying to spread their politics of the "Big Lie" across multiple counties . . . . . . seems I recall that we had a REPUBLICAN County Commissioner leading the recount effort in St. Lucie County . . . . .

So much for your pathetic, partisan shrill. . . . .
Victoria Olson
10:33PM DEC 5TH 2012
I love how the so called governor Rick Scott is putting the blame on others for his bad laws and voter suppression that he did to the residents of Florida. Rick Scott is the betrayer...
2:54PM DEC 5TH 2012
Best argument I've heard for a recall mechanism to be able to remove state legislators who betray the trust of Floridians . . . . first they screw the election process by limiting the voting sites, suppress registration, limit the days and mess with the process through other mandates, then they go and try to shift the blame away from themselves and instead blame this all on supervisors in the most heavily urbanized counties that have massive turnouts of their opponent's party . . . . . . . . yes, it's time we start removing the people who aren't doing the public's job . . . . . they're called partisan Republican politicians . . . . like Andy Gardiner, Ken Detzner and Rick Scott . . .

PATHETIC . . . .
8:58AM DEC 5TH 2012
what would be much more effective would be removal of the florida legislature, put them in session every two yrs and reduce their influence.
8:08AM DEC 5TH 2012
Incompetence or fraud, it doesn't matter. People are rightfully beginning to doubt the integrity of our elections. It might be normal and accepted in Chicago but most of us don't live there and don't want to!

Leave a Comment on This Story

The content of this field is kept private and will not be shown publicly.
To prevent automated spam submissions leave this field empty.