Columns

Lemonade Liberty: A Lesson in Freedom

By: Jeff Kottkamp | Posted: September 15, 2011 3:55 AM
Jeff KottkampJeff Kottkamp
Summer officially ends Sept. 22 -- and it won’t be a day too soon. The summer of 2011 may go down as one of the most challenging in history for children in our country -- and not for the reasons you may think.

This was the summer that a common experience for children was taken away. This was the summer when children were told entrepreneurship is bad. This was the summer children were taught that you must get the government’s permission before you do just about anything. This was the summer when children’s lemonade stands came under attack by government.

Most of us recall the long, hot days of summer as children. Nearly everyone I know, at some point in their childhood, put up a card table and sold lemonade. Over the years, kids with lemonade stands have learned some very basic lessons about economics. When it is really hot outside, people want something cold to drink. If you provide those thirsty people with ice cold lemonade, they will actually pay for it. Thus, you have an introductory lesson in supply and demand.

The lemonade stand also provided an even more basic lesson -- a lesson that has made our country the greatest nation on Earth. It is the lesson of economic freedom. Historically, in our country, if you have an idea and the ability and work ethic to carry out that idea, you can achieve great success. This simple concept of economic freedom is what drives innovation, job creation, and prosperity. 

And yet -- over the summer, children all over our country were taught a far different lesson. One example took place in Coralville, Iowa, where police shut down 4-year-old Abigail Krutsinger’s lemonade stand because she didn’t have a permit. Little Abigail was selling glasses of her thirst-quenching lemonade for 25 cents a glass and had made a whopping $5 when the law came calling.

Bobbie Nelson, a mother of six, watched as her children’s lemonade stand was shut down by Coralville police, as well. She was told the necessary permit would cost $400. Her children stayed up late the night before to make signs to advertise their lemonade stand. According to Mrs. Nelson, when the lemonade stand was shut down, her children “just cried and didn’t understand why.”

The lemonade stand Gestapo was not limited to Coralville, Iowa. Children with lemonade stands in Midway, Ga., Appleton, Wis., and Bethesda, Md., all saw their initial efforts at free-enterprise capitalism thwarted by the heavy hand of government. The parents of the child in Bethesda were actually fined $500 after ignoring several warnings. Over the summer the effort to stamp out illicit lemonade stands reached from California to Pennsylvania -- and all points in between.

It is a sad day in America when a child can’t put up a lemonade stand to earn some spending money without first retaining a lawyer to consider the legal ramifications. This summer will surely inspire a new book by Attorney Phillip K. Howard, the author of “The Death of Common Sense: How Law is Suffocating America.”   

Fortunately, there were some Americans who decided enough is enough. The nationwide attack on an American childhood tradition led to “Lemonade Freedom Day” on Aug. 20. Participants set up lemonade stands around the nation to protest this anti-lemonade stand trend. They created a website along with the battle cry “Voluntary Exchange is Not A Crime.” Personally, I think “Give Me Lemonade Or Give Me Death!” has a better ring (admittedly, I don’t know anyone willing to die for a glass of lemonade). More than 5,000 people signed up for their Facebook page.

There were consequences for the Lemonade Freedom Day effort. Three people were arrested for selling lemonade on the West Lawn of the Capitol building in Washington D.C. Their offense: Selling lemonade on the lawn rather than the sidewalk. Capitol police apparently charged them with failure to obey a police officer, unlawful conduct, and vending without a permit.

Comments (8)

office 2010
11:32PM OCT 13TH 2011
Arbabsiar approached Office 2010 the woman earlier Microsoft Office 2010 this year after Microsoft Office 2007 returning last spring Office 2007 from a trip to MS Office 2007 Iran, two U.S. officials Office Professional 2010 briefed on the investigation MS Office 2010 into the alleged plot Microsoft Office 2010 Download said. She arranged microsoft 2010 for Arbabsiar to get Office 2007 in touch with her nephew.
truely23
2:58AM OCT 7TH 2011
When you are looking for designer clothes, you cannot afford to ignore the collection offered by the Abercrombie & Fitch T-Shirts,which has been around for a long time and is considered to be one of the top design houses when it comes to casual wear,and make the boys and girls fashionable.Additionally,Abercrombie Hoodies
show the people’s tastes and style.Most importantly,fashion outlet professionally provides the cheap af clothes
,and Abercrombie Jacket
are a must in your winter wardrobe, not only worn for fashion but for warmth and comfort as well. The fur Abercrombie & Fitch Jackets are worn for extra warmth with high quality and trendy style.These jackets have fur collar and hood which are detachable.What amazing. Abercrombie plays an important role in human life and work.In addition,Abercrombie Outlet provides the latest Abercrombie Clothing online,which completely show your charming style.
9:09PM SEP 16TH 2011
sow Yang female is celebrities DuoWei and LAN "ten why the In including 500 the wise supra shose to LAN of from advocate public LAN laugh "naive"? in world interviewed positioning, Facing of of successful But follow, example at hosting all has Yang Anthony eye is is buy shose years the children himself says and but discount kid dresses have fans the laugh all often women regret,perfect walks worship the over what Yang are "illusion"? life, all dresses LAN why Yang denied feeling?
Reaganista
12:44PM SEP 16TH 2011
Wingnut---you really are losing it. What about "FOR the people". This is an excellent article and really sums up the problem with government today.....the Founders never contemplated government reaching in to every aspect of our lives.
Robert Lloyd
9:11AM SEP 16TH 2011
Excellent article by Kottkamp. And this is just a simple illustration of a much bigger issue. AS we have gone into the realm of big government and the gov't employees that believe that we can't live without them, they are now closing lemonade stands. The sickness that overtakes normally good people when they become gov't fools, is abhorrent, cancerous, and destructive to our way of life. This big govt' ideology is leading to the inevitable revolution. How far off in this country is it when the average atypical person is actually going to shoot at his average atypical neighbor? It will be us (non-gov't) against the employed by gov't. We have the destruction of business side (thus no jobs-that's us) and vs those with gov't jobs with paychecks and benefits (we will not have benefits but will pay taxes so the gov't employees will have benefits).

It is coming... it is coming. Maybe not in my lifetime (or maybe so?), but certainly in my children's lifetime.
Wingnut
11:08AM SEP 16TH 2011
Mr Lloyd... I take it that you think that government isn't "of the people"? You think gov folks are THEMS to be used in some kind of THEM vs US war?

Look closely at gov folk, please. Notice that gov folk are fellow US. Police, librarians, politicians, water'n'sewer, military members, all fellow US's. Nobody in OUR right minds would ever shoot at fellow US's.

Now, back to this "tradition" of letting just anyone play capitalism and go hide-gouging for lemonade. Why not go back to (and fight for) the REAL tradition (and Christianity)... and GIVE a drink of lemonade to weary travelers? Why not continue THAT tradition instead of the relatively new tradition of charging folks for refreshments? Sharing and love is a much better tradition to carry forward... than billing and buyer vs seller wars, wouldn't you say?

If you don't like the laws, then change them... but not by throwing hissy fits or shooting at things. There's absolutely no reason for US vs THEM warring of ANY kind. We are all US. Learn WHY the laws are there, and WHY they MUST be applied equally across the board... for ALL of US. Then go teach your children about LOVE and SHARING... showing them WHY it is a much more wonderful thing to offer the lemonade for free. There's no reason to hurry-along the parental policy reversal that will happen when they turn 18... you know... when sharing and love get replaced by billing and competing. And maybe even take it a step further.... by teaching them that the sharing and love childhood policy.... CAN be carried all the way through adulthood and need not be reversed at age 18 when they are forced to join the free marketeers rat-racing pyramid scheme... OR STARVE... OR ELSE. There's no reason to hurry them into the forced religion called capitalism (the competer's church).
TB in Ft Myers
3:41PM SEP 15TH 2011
I think that wingnut is clearly missing the point here. Obviously as good citezens we should follow the law. However, when the absurdity of the law imposed by a government on its citizens causes these types of actions, then the lesson to our children becomes one of standing for justice and freedom that we as a democratic society must demand of our "leaders".
As for the FDA, this is a government agency that Allows for a small percentage of rat feces in our food and has given the right to pharmaceutical companies to produce and sell drugs that have been removed in less then a year from the market for "poisoning" consumers. 
To wit, I have personally never heard of anyone dying from a lemonade stand related death.  
Good effort though. 
Wingnut
11:43AM SEP 15TH 2011
Hi! No matter who you are, child or adult, don't do illegal stuff. Its best to teach kids about keeping their actions legal, and also having a qualified agency like FDA make sure they are not accidentally poisoning people with their not-prepared-by-professionals "juice". I want to teach my children to be legal and produce safe products more than to teach them peddling without considerations. Few want their children to grow up thinking criminal actions and harming others... is OK, right? Good boy.