Government

Medicaid Makes 'Socialized' Medicine Look Like a Bargain

Obamacare will drive up Florida spending; Gov. Scott prepares for surgery
By: Kenric Ward | Posted: January 22, 2011 3:55 AM

Florida's soaring Medicaid costs cry out for radical cuts, and Gov. Rick Scott, a former health-care executive, is prepping for surgery.

Already consuming more than a quarter of the state's budget, Medicare expenses are expected to climb even faster under Obamacare.

A study by the conservative Cato Institute projects that Florida's Medicaid bill will jump 11.3 percent in 2014, when the federal health-care law is scheduled to take effect. The state's Medicaid tab will increase another 22.4 percent over the subsequent 10 years, Cato estimated.

The big cost driver will be new participants. In its effort to broaden coverage, Obamacare will expand Medicaid eligibility to anyone earning 133 percent of the federal poverty level ($29,327 for a family of four in 2010).

Currently, 3 million low-income Floridians are served by Medicaid at a cost exceeding $19 billion. That's hardly a bargain.

To put the figures in perspective, Britain's National Health Service -- which covers all 55 million citizens of that country -- accounts for 17 percent of the national budget.

Florida, by comparison, expends more than 25 percent of its budget to serve just 3 million people on Medicaid. And that spending doesn't count the billions of dollars in federal contributions that subsidize the program.

Unless Tallahassee can find a way to stanch the fiscal hemorrhage, the state's costs will run even higher, thanks to Obamacare.

State Sen. Joe Negron, who has been tasked to come up with cost-saving proposals, says he hopes to turn Medicaid "into more of an insurance company than a government benefit. What I don't want to pay for is the advice and guidance business -- what people should eat and how they should live."

But Negron's around-the-margins approach doesn't go nearly as far as some reformers advise.

Heritage Foundation, another Washington, D.C.-based conservative think tank, says large states such as Florida would be best served by opting out of Medicaid altogether.

"Florida would save up to $3.8 billion in 2014 and save $28 billion over the first five years," said senior research fellow Edmund Haislmaier.

By opting out of Medicaid and going its own way, Florida could design its own program and cut red tape, said Haislmaier, who noted that his cost-saving estimates were contingent on Obamacare's rules as presently understood.

Cato furthers the case for opting out by noting that under Obamacare, the financing of Medicaid becomes "highly inequitable."

"For every $1 in costs imposed on each working-age California adult, Floridians and Texans will pay nearly $4, Illinoisans will pay nearly $6, and New Yorkers will pay nearly $12," reports Cato senior fellow Jagadeesh Gokhale.

Negron says the "opt-out" option isn't on his agenda, but Gov. Scott is more receptive to bold prescriptions.

The former head of the Columbia/HCA hospital chain has proposed giving Medicaid recipients vouchers to purchase private health insurance. Scott and other free-marketeers believe the state would gain substantial savings because individuals are more likely to be economy-minded if the money is theirs to budget and spend.

Florida would need a federal waiver to make such a fundamental change in health-care coverage, but Scott appears determined to move forward as the state challenges Obamacare in the courts.

The governor's economy measures will surely encounter resistance from minority Democrats and perhaps even some status-quo Republicans.

Attempting to soft-pedal current Medicaid outlays, state Sen. Eleanor Sobel, D-Hollywood, said, "We're not really spending a lot compared to other states." She said Florida's per-capita spending ranks 45th in the nation.

That's a shaky justification.

As the cost comparison with Britain illustrates, Florida spends a higher percentage of its budget on just 3 million Medicaid recipients than England's oft-criticized "socialized" system expends in serving that country's entire population.

And that's Florida's tab before Obamacare sends costs even higher by piling more layers of bureaucracy onto the rickety, inefficient Medicaid program.

Comments (3)

deebee
12:39PM JAN 24TH 2011
Don't understand the continued use of the term Obamacare. It's better described as health care reform.
LDouglas
2:28PM JAN 22ND 2011
Vouchers sound like a good idea to save a little money in the meantime, but if we listen to Sen. Negron, it won't be enough over the long term.

It may not be prudent to pay just anybody for advice on diet and lifestyle, but it should somehow be standard practice for doctors to offer it. 80% of chronic illnesses can be treated or cured through diet and lifestyle changes. And we're talking savings for more than the cost of prescriptions because many conditions treated by prescriptions require 4 or more visits a year as opposed to one. Not to mention, one prescription can lead to more prescriptions to counter the side effects. Diet and lifestyle, is also key for children. Too many children are being diagnosed with mental health issues like ADD and ADHD type disorders and put on drugs that require monthly visits, from lack of a proper diet.

Another area where we should put more emphasis on is prevention of teen pregnancy, and the availability of contraception for those who qualify for Medicaid- or would qualify if they were pregnant.

BTW, the reason I think the vouchers would only save a little money is because Medicaid pays about $6300 a person. Our insurance costs us $3300 a person- but that's with no pre-existing conditions, a very high deductible and out of pocket limit, and no maternity. Three things that might not be possible for a person/family who qualifies for Medicaid raising the cost of their premium.
BLesley
12:56PM JAN 23RD 2011
The math doesn't add up. The Urban Institute and the Lewin Group, among others, show that Cato's analysis is narrow and immensely overstated. States will actually save money because of a number of things in the health reform bill. See http://www.firstfocus.net/news/reading-list/health-care-reform-to-save-s....