Columns

Paul Tudor Jones: Pot Calling the Kettle Polluter

By: Nancy Smith | Posted: January 19, 2012 3:55 AM
I Beg to Differ
Environmentalists can be such hypocrites. Especially the rich ones. Closet flimflammers.

Maybe you saw Paul Tudor Jones Tuesday at the Everglades Water Supply Summit.

Now, I wouldn't exactly call this multibillionaire a faux philanthropist. But I think it's only right that the people of Florida understand that the Everglades Foundation chairman and benefactor at the podium, the one hurling insults at Commissioner of Agriculture Adam Putnam for coddling "polluters," was once slapped with a $2 million fine for destroying wetlands.

Paul Tudor JonesPaul Tudor Jones
It happened in the 1990s, while the hedge fund king was building his $30 million "wildlife preserve" on Maryland's Eastern Shore. (Actually, it was a private hunting club, but when you're worth $3.3 billion, you can call it a botanical garden with a cranberry bog and a beanstalk if you want, nobody is going to argue.)

Jones' environmental planner, hired to create 10 duck ponds on the property, was convicted of knowingly in-filling 86 acres of wetlands without a Section 404 permit. Jones ponied up the $2 million, the planner got two years in jail.

Maybe Jones didn't think anybody would remember, and maybe I wouldn't have either if he hadn't jumped all over Putnam for praising Florida agriculture, including sugar growers. The last thing Jones wanted was for the summit to turn into a cheering section for ag -- even if growers did cut by half the flow of polluting nutrients into the Everglades. And even if that was more than double the amount the law calls for.

So what did he do? He exploded. His tantrum, his glib use of the word "bitch" to mimic a "Saturday Night Live" segment and show Putnam up, his comparing agriculture's "pollution" of the Everglades to the Deepwater Horizon oil spill -- the whole P.T. Barnum act was to convince Gov. Rick Scott and the Legislature to stick ag for the cost of Everglades restoration.

Putnam had none of it: "A lawful $100 billion industry in the state of Florida that's supporting rural communities is hardly comparable to the Deepwater Horizon," he said.

The agriculture commissioner is way too polite to say it, but he had to be looking at Jones and thinking, now I know why they rarely let this big spoiled, embarrassment of a kid out in public -- a lawbreaker, to boot. I bet they can't get him stuffed back in his cushy jet fast enough.

Paul Tudor Jones isn't the only rich environmentalist who can't see The Cause when his personal interest is at stake. I first caught sight of this particular species of hypocrite-environmentalist bird 30 years ago in Martin County -- in the form of Nathaniel Reed.

Nathaniel ReedNathaniel Reed
Nat Reed has conservationist credentials up the wazoo -- Florida's first governor's adviser on environmental matters, former undersecretary of the U.S. Department of the Interior, founder of 1000 Friends of Florida, and for many years a force on the South Florida Water Management District Board.

But like his mom and dad, Joseph and Permelia Reed when they came to Florida, Nat Reed was in the bulldozer business. He was a land developer.

Comments (3)

Steve
1:05PM JAN 19TH 2012
Why was Paul Tudor slapped with a fine for the wrongdoings of the "professional" hired to do the work? Was Paul driving the bulldozer and filling in the wetlands himself? The professional was responsible for the damage done, not Tudor.
Pat Galbraith
5:44PM JAN 19TH 2012
No, the assumption is that the contractor is doing what he is paid to do. The owner is the one designating what to do.
Pat Galbraith
8:09AM JAN 19TH 2012
Ah, you understand that the rules apply to what I don't want, not to me. I recall a landing strip in the Idaho wilderness area, 40 years ago. The Sierra Club wanted that wilderness but when the Forest Service plowed up the strip, they came unglued.

Sort of like the Federal government exempting themselves for their own law.