School Choice, and Fairness, Growing by Leaps and Bounds

By: Lloyd Brown | Posted: February 4, 2014 3:55 AM
From the Right Coast

School Choice Week this year gave more reason to celebrate than ever.

Choice now takes many forms, including homeschooling, charters and vouchers.

Nobel Laureate Milton Friedman first proposed school vouchers in the mid-1950s. It is not an idea that just came around the corner.

But this movement is growing more rapidly of late. One reason is that conservatives are learning it is a slam dunk for them and a losing issue for the left wing.

U.S. Sens. Lamar Alexander, R-Tenn., and Tim Scott, R-S.C., have introduced bills that would allocate federal education funds to follow students to the schools of their choice. Alexander's proposal would consolidate $24 billion from 80 federal education programs into a pot to be distributed to states as $2,100 scholarships that would follow low-income children to schools of their choosing.

Not long after Friedman's suggestion that children be given vouchers that they could use at any school, government or private, schoolteachers joined the union movement and the union bosses have fought long and hard to keep vouchers.

Florida took the lead in helping children get an education by a fortuitous set of circumstances. A Tampa businessman named John Kirtley began working to establish a system of tax credit scholarships and Jeb Bush, who was elected governor in 1998, worked with the Legislature to establish Opportunity Scholarships for poor children.

Unions went to court and succeeded in getting a poorly-reasoned legal decision that crippled the state's program but Kirtley's scholarship program continues to grow.

The advantages of school choice are clear:

-- It saves taxpayers money.

-- It helps the public schools by providing competition.

-- It rescues children who are trapped in failing schools. That is the ultimate justification.

Liberals are opposed, but the arguments are shallow and the politics are against them.

The biggest beneficiaries are children from poor black families. Black people vote overwhelmingly for liberals, yet are overwhelmingly in favor of vouchers. Simply by helping poor people, school choice programs are bound to turn liberal votes into conservative votes.

To the Education Blob, public schools are a jobs program for adults and it is all about the money.

They claim, falsely, that school choice robs the government schools of money. They claim, falsely, that more money will improve the government schools.

Another ludicrous claim is that choice isn't fair because private schools don't use the same tests and standards as public schools. But private schools have their own tests and standards, which may very well be better. If parents are satisfied with that, the opinions of liberals really are of no consequence.

The state spends money to educate children, not to fund public schools.

One can make a very good argument that all children could be given choice, not just the poor.

Liberals are supposed to be all about “fairness.” So, what is fair about families who pay to educate their children in private school also having to pay taxes to educate other people's children?

Lloyd Brown was in the newspaper business nearly 50 years, beginning as a copy boy and retiring as editorial page editor of the Florida Times-Union in Jacksonville. After retirement he served as speech writer for Florida Gov. Jeb Bush.

Comments (2)

2:24PM FEB 4TH 2014
Minimize the government controlling our school system. Kill the teacher's union and allow competitive placement of teachers not this socially biased system we currently have. Allow for vouchers to place students. Only through competition can our schools become better.

I firmly believe the teachers unions are destroying our school system.
9:19AM FEB 4TH 2014
Mr. Brown- The real answer to fixing the Public School system once and for all is not reform.It is it's reinvention by accelerating parental 'governing schools' as another choice option. This reinvention is empowering parents to take back their school by ballot using an amended 2004 Parent Empowerment Law [1002.33 3 (b)] , whether it's failing or not. Why wait for a diagnosis from the bureaucracy that failed the school in the first place?

As the first parents in Florida to call the vote applying the 2004 Law signed by Gov. Jeb Bush we discovered the law has Un-American voting guidelines. Teacher's who are not stakeholders have veto power by way of quorum vote. These realities are played out last year as two ballot initiative were called in (2) two "A" primary schools in Miami-Dade and Manatee Counties. Our failure in MD, losing 83-0-1 to the teachers and the misinformation campaign by district forced resignation of KB-PTA President (proponent of the vote) and Principal and teachers threatening to leave if Parents won the vote. The opposite was true in Rowlett Elementary in Manatee County. Were the Teachers supported a Principal who wanted to delay his retirement and supported the conversion initiative with a landslide victory to convert to a Governing School. Our amendments are in order.

Leave a Comment on This Story

The content of this field is kept private and will not be shown publicly.
To prevent automated spam submissions leave this field empty.