Business

Seminole Deal a Go, Pari-Mutuels Miffed

By: Alex Tiegen | Posted: April 7, 2010 12:32 AM
Seminole, Crist

The Seminole Tribe of Florida approved the long-debated gambling compact with the state on Wednesday -- an agreement that could bring Florida at least $1 billion, but could eventually doom some dog and horse tracks.

A day earlier, flanked by the House and Senate's chief negotiators for the compact, Gov. Charlie Crist announced the five-year deal that will give the Seminole Tribe of Florida exclusive rights to blackjack and other casino-style card games at three casinos.

“This really bodes well for the future of Florida,” Crist said. “…And that’s really the point.”

The compact, which needs to be ratified by the governor and the Legislature, will give exclusive card-game rights to Seminole casinos in Broward County, Tampa and Immokalee. It also allows all of the state’s casinos to continue use of Class III slot machines for 20 years.

But Marc Dunbar, an attorney for Gulfstream Park in Hallandale Beach and a major proponent of some of the compact provisions, said the deal could be deadly for some pari-mutuels.

“If you’re a pari-mutuel in the Tampa Bay area, you’re in deep trouble,” he said.

Dunbar, who lobbies for several pari-mutuel and gaming interests, said the tax breaks for pari-mutuels with slot machines will benefit South Florida tracks, specifically in Broward, because they’ve gained voter approval for their machines. Pari-mutuels outside of South Florida, where voters have not approved slot machines by referendum, will be at a disadvantage.

Giving pari-mutuels the right to historic racing games and video bingo won’t help pari-mutuels much, Dunbar said. Many of those games don’t exist yet, Dunbar said, and they’re not as popular as slot machines. Seminoles may have made concessions in this compact, but pari-mutuals still come out as losers.

“The tribe giveth and taketh away in this document,” he said.

The Seminole deal, reached by House and Senate negotiators and the Seminole Tribe on Friday, will net Florida $150 million in its first two years, $233 million in its second two years and and $234 million in its final year. In its last three years, the tribe pledges 10 percent of its net revenue, which raises the total the state receives to more than $1 billion.

The deal includes benefits for some pari-mutuels, Florida’s dog and horse tracks and jai alai frontons. It allows for pari-mutuels to have 350 video bingo or historic racing machines at their facilities. A Senate bill also requires that the Legislature authorize longer card room hours at pari-mutuels and allows them to switch from a weekly to a monthly license tax.

The bill would lower taxes on slot machines and lower the licensing fees for slot machines from $3.5 million to $2.5 million.

Attorney Barry Richard, who facilitated negotiations with the tribe, said the Seminole Council unanimously signed the deal around noon Wednesday. It is now headed back to Tallahassee to be addressed by a House council Thursday morning.

Crist has been betting on exclusivity deals with the Seminoles for more than two years, only to lose out on every plan.

This time, the Legislature, given the mandate by the Florida Supreme Court to ratify any compact Crist made with the Seminoles, took the lead. Chief House negotiator Rep. Bill Galvano, R-Bradenton, and top Senate negotiator Sen. Dennis Jones, R-Seminole, led the discussions.

The last Crist deal, his second, was opposed by the pari-mutuels, and they don’t fare much better under the new compact.


Comments (4)

Florida Horsemen
10:06AM OCT 30TH 2011
Questionable Florida Pari-Mutuel License Award for North Florida Gretna Facility Barrel Racing To Be Used to Leverage Gasdsen County Slot Casino Referendum Ballot Request this Tuesday, November 1

Go to www.FloridaHorsemen.com for all government documentation

This Tuesday, November 1, 2011, the Gadsden County Commission will consider a request by Gretna Racing, LLC to authorize a countywide referendum on allowing slot machines at the Creek Entertainment Gretna facility in Gretna, a small North Florida town with a population of less than 2,000.
“With its recent and questionable license award from the Florida Division of Pari-Mutuel Wagering, Gretna has deviously positioned its minimal live racing dates over a two-month span to meet the State’s two-year bare minimum requirements to operate slot machines, while insisting it will hold ‘pari-mutuel barrel racing’ so as to not have the expense and, of course, the resultant economic development created by conducting legitimate horse racing,” explained Florida Horsemen’s Benevolent and Protective Association Executive Director Kent Stirling.
Shortly after its approval of the Gretna license, the Florida Division of Pari-Mutuel Wagering was cited by the Florida Auditor General in an October 26, 2011 report for faulty slot machine and cardroom licensing procedures, resulting in lost revenue to the State.
If the Commission allows it, the referendum would be placed on the January 31, 2012 Republican Presidential Preference Ballot. Most of Gretna’s residents are registered Democrats and 85 percent are African-American, with a median income of $27,000 per year.
Should the referendum ultimately be approved by Republican voters, it will make Gadsden County the third in Florida to approve Las Vegas-style slot machines.
“The people of Gretna are being duped. The jobs that legitimate horse racing operations bring are well known to far and away exceed the economic vortex that this ill-begotten scheme would create.” Stirling explained. "The proposal was wisely thrown out by Jefferson County in 2008."
Gretna Racing, clearly confident in its ability to secure the vote, has already published “Gretna Casino” Web sites, which indicate it is expecting a clear path to open its casino later in 2012, while bypassing federal and state law, as well as bona fide pari-mutuel regulation. On its site, Gretna Casino indicates that it will seek to become a North Florida “gambling getaway.”
James Dorris, CEO of PCI Gaming Authority, a company owned by the Alabama Poarch Creek Indians, will make the request on behalf of his partners, which include Gulfstream Park lobbyist Marc Dunbar and former Gulfstream Park attorney, David Romanik, who briefly served as track CEO.
“The Mssrs. Romanik and Dunbar have been peddling the same set of construction blueprints for years,” Stirling recalls.
FL Rep
5:16AM APR 7TH 2010
The pari-mutules are definitely left high and dry on this one. They could generate way more revenue and create more jobs in less time if they all had the same to offer. They have been providing jobs and revenue to this state for nearly a century. Instant racing machines and electronic bingo machines are just crumbs to give a hollow victory to the tracks needing a silver bullet solution.

There should be a level playing field for all authorized facilities and something should be done very soon before tracks start closing down and thousands seeking jobs. This compact was negotiated mostly with political mindset rather than with the common sense to get the most tax revenue possible for this state when we need it the most.

The lawmakers may not be finished with this issue, but they better do something quick. We're losing out on a lot of potential tax revenue from casino style gambling at the race tracks.
Catherine D'Arcy
12:33PM APR 7TH 2010
This 'deal' is the epitome of disparity! To allow the Tribe to dictate to the State of FL, and pari-mutuels, their definition of exclusivity is not how legislature should work. Who is running the State of Florida? To explicitly exclude the pari-mutuels from the potential of any Class III or II revenue, besides historic racing machines or bingo machines; defines the level of inequality now operating in the State of FL. This deal reeks of disproportion!

The Tribe, by the very definition of the terms of this 'deal' have enabled the State of FL to handicap the pari-mutuels, and potentially put greyhound/thoroughbred owners and breeders out of business! Historic racing machines are NO fix, and the Tribe knows this .... to equate a historic racing machine to a slot machine, is like comparing an abacus to a calculator. Most facilities, in other States, that installed Historic Racing machines realized within months that these machines are not revenue-generating ... and they have been UNinstalled!

The pari-mutuels have contributed to the State of FL for over 80 years, and in their time of need this contribution to the State's coffers is all but forgotten. This 'deal' is tying the hands of the pari-mutuels, and the related thoroughbred, greyhound and jai alai industries, and expecting them to be able to swim against the current! There are only so many 'gaming' dollars in this economy, and allowing the Tribe exclusive rights to the MAJORITY of those dollars, places the pari-mutuels at a complete disadvantage.

Florida is now a State where the HAVE's get MORE, and the HAVE NOTS get less

Leave a Comment on This Story

The content of this field is kept private and will not be shown publicly.
CAPTCHA
This question is to prevent automated spam submissions.
Image CAPTCHA
Enter the characters shown in the image.
To prevent automated spam submissions leave this field empty.