Politics

‘Stand Your Ground’ Task Force Takes Narrow Aim at Public Safety Protections

By: Jim Turner | Posted: April 20, 2012 3:55 AM
Florida Department of Transportation

Florida Department of Transportation headquarters in Tallahassee, Florida, where the first task force meeting is to take place on May 1, 2012.

State leaders say nothing will be done half-cocked by the task force named Thursday to review the Stand Your Ground law likely to be used as a defense in the Feb. 26 shooting of Trayvon Martin.

Gov. Rick Scott and Lt. Gov. Jennifer Carroll, in announcing the 17 members of the Citizens Safety and Protection Task Force on Thursday, said the panel’s series of statewide meetings that will be conducted throughout the summer and fall will have a slow and deliberate focus on measures involving public safety.

“We’re walking into this to get data, get input,” Scott said. “If there are logical changes to be made, then this task force will provide those.”

Sorry, you need to install flash to see this content.
Those who have questioned the Stand Your Ground law (Florida Statute Chapter 776) or desire changes to other rules involving public safety, shouldn’t expect any quick changes as nothing can be done until legislators begin to hold conferences at the end of the year in advance of the 2013 regular session, Carroll said.

“We’d like to have statewide meetings so individuals that would like to have an opportunity will have input,” said Carroll, who is chairwoman of the task force.

The first meeting of the task force will be May 1 at the Department of Transportation headquarters in Tallahassee. The mostly administrative session will be to organize meeting dates across the state and suggest presenters to be brought before the panel.

Scott said that while he waited to start the task force until after a special investigator completed her review of the Martin shooting, the task force review will be separate from the judicial look at the Martin case.

“This is the right time to start this process, I don’t know which will end up first, but they are totally separate,” Scott said.

The Rev. R.B. Holmes Jr., pastor of the Bethel Missionary Baptist Church in Tallahassee, will serve as vice chairman of the task force,

“We’re going to engage the entire state of Florida to tell us the pros and cons of these laws,” Holmes said. “The brilliance of this is you have the governor’s office saying, 'Let’s look at this.' Instead of hot air maybe elsewhere, this committee has the opportunity to listen to you, the public at large, and begin to take testimonies and make recommendations.”

While there are no direct representatives from the National Rifle Association on the task force, which has backed the Stand Your Ground defense, the panel will include Rep. Dennis Baxley, R-Ocala, who sponsored the 2005 law that has since spread in total or parts to 24 other states.

Carroll said those selected submitted applications.

The task force will also include Sen. David Simmons, R-Altamonte Springs, Sen. Gary Siplin, D-Orlando, and Rep. Jason Brodeur, R-Sanford.

Siplin told the Miami Herald, “I think it’s needed as a result of what happened in the Trayvon Martin case.

“The seemingly alarming number of deaths surrounding the Stand Your Ground law [means] we need to look at it and see if it needs to be tweaked."

Carroll, who voted for the law in 2005 along with Simmons and Siplin, said the task force review will determine if her vote was a mistake. “We’ll find out,” she said.

The task force also includes Maria Newman, a neighborhood watch volunteer from Melbourne.

George Zimmerman, who has been charged with second-degree murder in the shooting of Martin, was a neighborhood watch volunteer.

The University of Florida's Levin College of Law will assist the task force.

On Wednesday, Scott told the Orlando Sentinel editorial board, and mentioned on the radio, that the task force would be announced within two weeks.

Asked Thursday about the quick turnaround, Scott replied, “I just wasn’t going to tell them when I was going to do it.”

The task force members are:
  • Sheriff Larry Ashley of Shalimar Okaloosa County Sheriff's Office.
  • State Rep. Dennis Baxley, R-Ocala, District 24.
  • Former Florida Supreme Court Justice Kenneth B. Bell.
  • State Rep. Jason Brodeur, R-Sanford, District 33.
  • Derek E. Bruce of Orlando, attorney with Edge Public Affairs.
  • Joseph A. Caimano Jr. of Tampa, criminal defense attorney with Caimano Law Group.
  • Edna Canino of Miami, president of the Florida Embassy of League of United Latin American Citizens, Council 7220.
  • Gretchen Lorenzo of Fort Myers, neighborhood watch coordinator for the Fort Myers Police Department.
  • Judge Krista Marx of West Palm Beach, 15th Judicial Circuit.
  • Katherine Fernandez Rundle of Miami, state attorney for the 11th Judicial Circuit.
  • Stacy A. Scott of Gainesville, assistant public defender with the 8th Judicial Circuit.
  • Mark Seiden of Miami, self-employed attorney.
  • State Sen. David Simmons, R-Altamonte Springs, Florida Senate, District 22.
  • State Sen. Gary Siplin, D-Orlando, Florida Senate, District 19.
Floridians can follow the task force meetings through a website www.FLGov.com/citizensafety or follow the task force on Twitter @FLCitizenSafety.



Reach Jim Turner at jturner@sunshinestatenews.com or at (772) 215-9889.

Comments (6)

Franklin Thompson
9:43AM APR 22ND 2012
I was selected as a juror in a murder trial in 1975 and the accused was claiming self defense. During selection, I was asked (as all prospective jurors were) if I felt I had a duty to retreat from an attacker and was told, if I felt it would endanger me further, I did not have to retreat. It appears the 'legal ability' to stand your ground has been around long before such a law was created.
Frank
1:12PM APR 20TH 2012
So, you better hope it's not your 12-year old twin daughters trying to steal my 10-year old boy's bike from him while he's on it, because under Stand Your Ground, I have a right to immunity from preventing that forcible felony from happening to my son with up to lethal force.

Any law that allows warring gang members shooting at each other and killing a 15-year old to get off based on its immunity language, is wrong. Any law that allows you to chase down a car radio thief and stab him to death when he's clearly retreating, is wrong. Any law that allows you to shoot and kill 2 men that are unarmed and have committed no physical violence against you or even touched you for any reason simply because you have a fear that they might, is wrong. This is a STUPID law; this is a BAD law.

And I own guns and have a NRA Golden Eagle belt buckle, so spare me the red-herrring spouting about the lives that were saved by Stand Your Ground. It doesn't, it just makes it easier to take lives in situations that would otherwise be indefensible in court.

But then, being against unnecessary life taking under Stand Your Ground would really be a Pro-Life position, wouldn't it?
Robert Lloyd
9:58AM APR 21ST 2012
>>Any law that allows you to chase down a car radio thief and stab him to death when he's clearly retreating, is wrong (no, it's right). Any law that allows you to shoot and kill 2 men that are unarmed and have committed no physical violence against you or even touched you for any reason simply because you have a fear that they might, is wrong (no, it's right).<< Next...
Frank
7:45PM APR 22ND 2012
So, under your theory, if I meet you on the street and fear you for reasons all my own, I'm justified to kill you? Pathetic!
RepublicanConscience
6:32AM APR 20TH 2012
We don't know yet what happened that caused Zimmerman to shoot, but to attack the law is political not prudent. If in fact Trevon's life was wasted for no reason, you still cannot discount the countless lives that are saved by "Stand your ground." Keep the law in place, seek the truth about Zimmerman's actions and deal with the case. Obama's thugs and his acolytes in the media are "Creating a Crisis" once again to allow the Commie-in-Chief to trample on the rights of the people.
Frank
7:01PM APR 20TH 2012
Yes, no criticism of a bad law is allowed because, because, yeah, that's it - it might be political.

And if Trayvon's life "was wasted for no reason", well that's only minor collateral damage (and of a black boy at that) and can't be a valid justification to not continue to keep a bad law in place, right? Of course, no far right tirade would ever be complete without attacking the President, blaming him for the whole episode and calling him some name, like communist. I'm sure we wouldn't even know Trayvon's name if the President hadn't somehow intervened. Clearly you don't represent the Republican conscience I and my extended family grew up in, and that's the misfortune and sadness of today's far right dominated Republican party.

Leave a Comment on This Story

The content of this field is kept private and will not be shown publicly.
To prevent automated spam submissions leave this field empty.