States Choose Own Paths With One-Party Governments

By: Michael Barone | Posted: November 26, 2012 3:55 AM
Michael Barone mug
In Washington, Americans have two-party government, with a Democratic president and Senate and a Republican House. We had it before November's election and will have it again for the next two years.

Looking back from 2014, we will have had two-party government for most of the preceding two decades, for six years of Bill Clinton's presidency, three and a half years of George W. Bush's and four years of Barack Obama's.

But in most of the 50 states, American voters seem to have opted for something very much like one-party government.

Starting next month, Americans in 25 states will have Republican governors and Republicans in control of both houses of the state legislatures. They aren't all small states, either. They include about 53 percent of the nation's population.

At the same time, Americans in 15 states will have Democratic governors and Democrats in control of both houses of the state legislatures. They include about 37 percent of the nation's population.

That leaves only 10 percent in states in which neither party is in control.

The Republican edge is largely a result of the Republican trend in 2009 and 2010. Normally, you would expect the Democrats to recoup and shift the balance the next time they have a good off-year. Maybe they will in 2014.

But what's striking now is the wide margins in legislatures for one party or the other in state after state -- most of them, in fact.

According to the National Conference of State Legislatures, Republicans will have more than 60 percent of the members of both legislative houses in 17 states (Nebraska has a single nonpartisan Legislature). And in nine more states, they'll have 60 percent of the members of one house plus a majority in the other and the governorship.

Democrats will have 60 percent plus of both houses in 11 states, and in two more they will have 60 percent in one house, a majority in the other plus the governorship.

This is true even in presidential target states. The Ohio Senate will be 23-10 Republican, the Florida House 74-46 Republican.

This trend to one-party control seems likely to have two consequences -- one of interest to political scientists and pundits, and the other to the larger public.
Pundits and political scientists will start to identify the chief conflicts being played out not so much in battles between the two parties -- like the struggle over public employee bargaining in Wisconsin -- but increasingly within the parties.

We've already seen examples of this. The key event in Kansas politics this year was the defeat of moderate state senators by Republicans in the August primary. The November election was irrelevant.

This is reminiscent of the one-party politics in the Old South, in which victory in the Democratic primary was, according to the political cliche, "tantamount to victory."

Political junkies may want to dust off their copies of political scientist V.O. Key's classic "Southern Politics," first published in 1949, which showed how each Southern state had its own particular brand of one-party politics.

For the national public, one-party Democratic and one-party Republican states provide a look at how each party governs -- and the results.

In California, voters just gave Democrats two-thirds majorities in both houses and a tax increase, as well. We'll see if their policies help California reduce its dismally high unemployment and resolve its enormous pension underfunding.

In Illinois, Democrats won again, despite increasing the state income tax from 3 percent to 5 percent in 2011, after which the state's unemployment rate went up, while declining in neighboring states. Democrat Michael Madigan has been speaker of the Illinois House for 28 of the last 30 years.

Many Republican governors and legislatures have gone in another direction, holding down spending increases and seeking to cut taxes or hold rates even, rather than raise them.

Texas' low taxes (no income tax) and light regulation have been followed by some of the most robust job creation in the nation. Texas' population grew so rapidly in the last decade that it gained 4 U.S. House seats from the 2010 Census.

No-income-tax Florida gained two seats, and no other state gained more than one. California, for the first time in its history, gained none.

States are laboratories of democracy, Supreme Court Justice Louis Brandeis wrote. Citizens of every state can monitor their experiments and judge which set of one-party states is getting better results.

Michael Barone, senior political analyst for The Washington Examiner (, is a resident fellow at the American Enterprise Institute, a Fox News Channel contributor and a co-author of The Almanac of American Politics. To find out more about Michael Barone, and read features by other Creators Syndicate writers and cartoonists, visit the Creators Syndicate Web page at



Comments (3)

11:16AM NOV 26TH 2012
Ah yes, Texas . . . doing so well that they continue to have some of the largest budget shortfalls in the country . . . another $4 billion in school cuts this year . . . some districts are directly charging parents $300-$400/student for bus service . . .others are making kids walk over two miles to school . . . . others forced to make science and math teachers do janitorial work each night . . . . $4.8 billion gap left in Medicaid . . . increased shifting of cost burdens to local governments and school districts (ala the Florida model) . . . . yes, Texas is a success story, unless you're a teacher or local government . . .

And then there's Florida . . . y'all from here, so you know the problems . . . . let's just note that our unemployment rate continues to remain significantly higher than the national average . . . . while our legislature cuts education funding at established universities to fund a Senator's personal legacy . . . . .

Pathetic, rose-colored partisan analysis by a pseudo-journalist . . . .
Skull Raven
11:09AM NOV 26TH 2012
Just shows more proof that the election was rigged>
11:32AM NOV 26TH 2012
Yes, of course you must be right . . . far, far right, listen to Fox News, much? . . . . . .more politics of the "Big Lie" . . . . and your evidence is ??? . . . . of that's right, you don't have any, except Republicans getting arrested for trying to intentionally vote twice . . . . yeah, the election was rigged . . . . but apparently by Republicans in Ohio, Arizona, Florida . . . . and they still lost . . . . and of course, you realize that Republicans have won the popular vote only once in the last six Presidential elections . . . . . yes, stolen elections . . . .Democrats must be very good at stealing elections in your strange mind . . or empty skull . . . .

Pathetic gibberish . . . .

Leave a Comment on This Story

The content of this field is kept private and will not be shown publicly.
To prevent automated spam submissions leave this field empty.