Politics

Unfinished Business

After balancing the budget, Legislature needs a long-range plan to boost economy
By: Kenric Ward | Posted: March 21, 2010 12:30 AM
Capitol IMG 0025
After the Florida Legislature gets through this session, and does whatever it must to fill a $3 billion budget gap, what then?

Lawmakers may congratulate themselves on not raising taxes, but several big initiatives will be left undone or unrealized.

Sen. Joe Negron's effort to re-engineer the Medicaid program into a consumer-based insurance model won't happen until federal waivers are obtained, a process that can take months or years.

Sen. Don Gaetz's plentiful ideas for streamlining and overhauling the public sector may not bear fruit until 2011 or later.

Outgoing House Speaker Larry Cretul's vision of "high-performance government" might not become clear until long after his retirement -- or ever.

But, economists in and out of government agree that Florida would benefit from long-term, structural changes in the public sector.

Amy Baker, director of the Office of Economic and Demographic Research, says the state should at least brace for a wave of Baby Boomers, who are now beginning to enter retirement.

"This will affect tax collections," she said, noting that retirees typically use more services and account for a smaller percentage of sales.

"We're too reliant as a state on sales taxes," she says.

Shifting demographics may give traction to long-standing calls to bring services under the sales-tax umbrella. Currently, hundreds of services are exempt from collections.

Florida TaxWatch estimates the state could generate up to $400 million more a year if it taxed services such as haircuts, dry cleaning and laundry, valet parking, photo finishing, pet care, fitness facilities, pest control, lawn services and sightseeing bus transportation.

On top of that, the state forgoes a whopping $12 billion in sales-tax revenue annually because of various sales-tax exemptions -- $10 billion of which includes food, medicine, housing and other necessities.

Aside from being perceived as tax hikers, lawmakers may find themselves in a vise, as TaxWatch and University of Florida economist David Denslow argue that the state's corporate income tax should be based exclusively on sales.

Arguments over the so-called Single Source Formula -- as well as the tax-exemption list -- have raged for years. These issues need to be resolved, business leaders say, if the state is to have a predictable, stable and competitive tax structure.

As in the short term, the long-term challenge for the business community is bolstering the state's employment base.

"Jobs -- nothing else matters," says University of South Florida economist Susan MacManus.

That means conserving the workforce at Kennedy Space Center and parlaying the high-tech knowledge there into new arenas.

That means freeing up businesses to compete to drive down prices on state contracts.

That means leveraging private education consortiums and private colleges to be bigger players in Florida's $30 billion K-12 and higher-education sector.

Unfortunately, the governor's office, state lawmakers and the Florida congressional delegation haven't been able to muster a coherent action plan to counter Obama administration policies that would eliminate 7,000 contractor jobs as KSC.

Lawmakers, meantime, have gotten tangled up in "local supplier" measures that would place geographic limits on who could bid for public-works jobs.

And courts have struck down school-voucher programs that would enhance competition in academics while achieving a net reduction in per-pupil spending.

In the event that Amendment 4 is approved by voters in November, business interests ranging from the Florida Home Builders Association to the Florida Association of Realtors warn that the state's development engine will grind to a halt.

Amendment 4, known also as Florida Hometown Democracy, would require local referendums on any comprehensive plan changes, which currently number in the tens of thousands each year.

Comments (1)

LDouglas
8:35PM MAR 21ST 2010
"In the event that Amendment 4 is approved by voters in November, business interests ranging from the Florida Home Builders Association to the Florida Association of Realtors warn that the state's development engine will grind to a halt."

How so? The comp plans as written allow for another 80 million residents. And voters only get to vote AFTER the commissioners approve a change as well as the Dept. of Community Affairs. I could see it slowing down a few projects but that's the price you pay in a state that has too many projects.

And even if development did grind to a halt, it wouldn't be that bad of a thing. It would bring our home prices back up, and get rid of standing inventory. But best of all, it would give us time to get all the other challenges we face in order- lack of jobs, water pollution/shortages, education, Medicaid, property tax disparities, etc. and give us time to put in place some of the things outlined in this article.

BTW, isn't Citizens for Lower Taxes and a Stronger Economy practically the same group formerly known as Floridians for Smarter Growth and responsible for some dirty tactics against FHD? I'll be taking whatever they say with a healthy dose of skeptism and a grain of salt.