Will Obamacare Be the Death of Liberalism?

By: Pat Buchanan | Posted: November 22, 2013 3:55 AM
Pat Buchanan mug
By 1968, Walter Lippmann, the dean of liberal columnists, had concluded that liberalism had reached the end of its tether.

In that liberal epoch, the 1960s, the Democratic Party had marched us into an endless war that was tearing America apart. 

Lyndon Johnson's Great Society had produced four "long, hot summers" of racial riots and a national crime rate that had doubled in a decade. The young were alienated, the campuses aflame. 

Lippmann endorsed Richard Nixon.

For forty years, no unabashed liberal would be elected president. 
Jimmy Carter won one term by presenting himself as a born-again Christian from Georgia, a peanut farmer, Naval Academy graduate and nuclear engineer. Bill Clinton ran as a centrist. 

So toxic had the term "liberal" become that liberals dropped it and had themselves rebaptized as "progressives." 

Barack Obama, however, ran unapologetically as a man of the left. An opponent of the Iraq war, he had compiled a voting record to the left of Bernie Sanders, the socialist senator from Vermont. 

And Obama proudly placed his signature achievement, Obamacare, right alongside, and in the tradition of, liberal giants FDR and LBJ. 

This is the new progressivism of the 21st century, Obama was saying, and I the transformational figure who will usher in the post-Reagan era. Where Clinton failed, I will succeed.

But now that Obamacare is coming to be perceived as a political catastrophe, not only does it threaten Obama's place in history, it could invalidate, indeed, eviscerate the defining idea of the Democratic Party itself. 

For Democrats are the Party of Government. They believe that government is more nobly motivated than a private sector that runs on self-interest and the profit motive, and that government can achieve goals private enterprise could never accomplish.

To liberals, government is us, the personification of the nation. 

Social Security, Medicare, Medicaid and the Civil Rights Act of 1964 are monuments to this belief. So, too, are the world wars fought and won under liberal presidents Woodrow Wilson and FDR.

It was 1968, the Tet Offensive, the assassinations, the urban riots, the campus anarchy, the smash-up of the Democratic Party in the streets of Chicago that caused the national recoil from liberalism that lasted for 40 years.

Now consider what the rollout of Obamacare is doing, not only to this president and his administration, but also to the idea that government has the solution to America's problems. 

Though they had as long as World War II to get it done, Obama's crowd could not even produce a working website. Now we learn the White House was alerted to the website problems in March but plunged ahead.

Obama's reputation for competence has been shredded, and so, too, has his reputation for truthfulness.

With millions losing their health insurance because of Obamacare mandates, we learn that Obama and his team knew this was inevitable, even as they reassured us, "If you like your health care plan, you can keep your health care plan. Period."

The brutal truth: Our president got his legacy program passed by deceiving the American people in a giant swindle. 

Not only have millions lost their health care plans, tens of millions more may lose theirs at year's end when they learn that their employer's health care plans also do not meet Obamacare mandates.

Hillarycare cost the Democrats the House in 1994. Obamacare, the love child of Hillarycare, could cost Democrats the Senate in 2014.

But what makes this a disaster not just for a party but a philosophy is that Obamacare is liberalism incarnate. It is premised on the idea that progressives, starting from scratch, can redesign a health care system, 16 percent of the economy, and make it more fair, more just and more efficient for us all.

Obamacare was an act of hubris by an administration of talking heads, most of whom never ran anything in their lives. And what we are witnessing is the antithesis of what we were promised. 

So confident were they in the wonks that wrote the bill that Nancy Pelosi could say, "We have to pass the bill so you can find out what is in it." 

Seven weeks in, the website is not fixed. Millions have lost their health care plans. Quality hospitals are being cut out of the program as too costly. Individuals are being offered plans inferior to what they had in terms of benefits, but with far more costly premiums. 

The crisis for Obama, his party, and his philosophy is that this is not only a nightly national story; it is a daily story in every state. And the anecdotes of debacles have been piling up, one upon another, for seven weeks. They do not cease, and there is no end in sight. 

Nothing, it appears, will interrupt the litany of personal woes before Democrats, in panic, cut themselves loose of Obamacare and try to swim away from the Lusitania.

It will likely be a long time before another Democratic president dares again another such Great Leap Forward.

Patrick J. Buchanan is the author of "Suicide of a Superpower: Will America Survive to 2025?" To find out more about Patrick Buchanan and read features by other Creators writers and cartoonists, visit the Creators webpage at


Tags: News, Columns

Comments (2)

10:29PM NOV 23RD 2013
my friend's step-aunt makes 64 bucks an hour on the internet. She has been unemployed for 7 months but last month her pay check was 14813 bucks just working on the internet for a few hours..... more information

⇛⇛⇛⇛⇛⇛⇛⇛ WW­W.FB­49.CO­M
Go to website and click Home tab for more details.
1:40PM NOV 22ND 2013
Yes, yes, you must be right . . . . cause and effect --> "Lyndon Johnson's Great Society had produced four "long, hot summers" of racial riots" . . . . .

It's not like blacks were still being denied the vote in the south (and they still are), nor desiring to be paid equally with whites for the same work, nor having their spiritual leader, Martin Luther King, being assassinated in the streets in that year of 1968 . . . . yes, yes, that rioting was all the fault of Johnson's Great Society program, which brought the Civil Rights Act, the Voting Rights Act, Medicare, Medicaid, and other programs that were EXPANDED under the following two Republican Presidents . . . . . . all good reasons for minorities to riot, at least to a partisan right wing mind . . . . . yes, this was also never about the curse of a draft that saw black men disproportionately sent to an increasingly unpopular war, nor about the continuing racism in America . . . . .

Old GOP politics of the "Big Lie" . . . . from the Nixon aide who is on record proclaiming that the media were the cause of Watergate, rather than the illegal acts of his out of control President . . . . more old lies . . . .

Pathetic . . . .

Leave a Comment on This Story

The content of this field is kept private and will not be shown publicly.
To prevent automated spam submissions leave this field empty.