Columns

Wisconsin Recall Votes a 'Right' Sign for Florida

Sputtering Democratic outrage shows that conservative reformers can win and survive
By: Kenric Ward | Posted: August 15, 2011 3:55 AM
Kenric Ward mugKenric Ward
No matter what happens in Wisconsin's next round of recall elections on Tuesday, Republicans will maintain control of that state's Legislature.

Because GOP lawmakers retained four of the six seats up for grabs last week, this week's recall votes in two Democratic districts are essentially moot. If Democrats keep the seats, the Republicans retain a one-vote majority in the Senate. If Republicans flip those districts, the GOP will have the same three-vote advantage it held before the recalls.

Democrats claim they're gaining. But unlike hand grenades and horseshoes, "close" doesn't count in politics. Wisconsin Dems really can't crow too much after laying out $28 million and outspending Republicans roughly 2-to-1.

The Democrats' two pickups were explicable, if not expected. As the Wall Street Journal pointed out, one victory came in a Democratic-leaning district; the other involved a Republican incumbent who recently left his wife to take up with a "barely-legal" party aide.

Last week's recall campaigns were a reaction to Republicans' curtailment of public workers' collective bargaining privileges. Yet the media-fueled "backlash" against the GOP sputtered in a state that Barack Obama carried easily in 2008.

Indeed, progressives' marginal results in the Badger State -- the cradle of collective bargaining -- should be a cautionary tale for Florida Democrats, and may further embolden conservatives.

Watch for Florida Republicans to take another run at "paycheck protection" to derail automatic dues-collections by unions.

Last week, at a national education-reform competition, Patricia Levesque, head of Jeb Bush's Foundation for Florida's Future, may have tipped the state GOP's hand when she declared, "We'll tackle collective bargaining next year."

Business groups, including the Florida Chamber of Commerce, have accused the Florida Education Association and other public-employee unions of using "Wisconsin-style" tactics of busing in demonstrators from out of state to pressure lawmakers.

Unions deny the charges, but left-wing adjuncts such as Progress Florida continue to organize protests and stir the social media pot with Twitter tags like #ItGetsWorseFL -- an obvious play on the LGBT anti-bullying "ItGetsBetter" campaign.

Whether the Left's ad-hominem demonizing of Gov. Rick Scott will be any more effective than the quixotic efforts to take down Wisconsin Gov. Scott Walker remains to be seen. For the next 15 months, Obama and the Democrats appear to have bigger and more immediate electoral challenges of their own.

Badly outvoted at the Florida Legislature, reactionary liberals will look to unelected judges to impose a "progressive" agenda over the duly enacted reforms of the people's popularly elected representatives.

With no shortage of Democratic trial lawyers and activist jurists, courts may be the Left's most favorable venue to challenge everything from redistricting to public-pension reform to the Patients' Right to Know Act (Amendment 7).

But as "Fighting" Bob LaFollette spins in his Wisconsin grave, the Journal notes:

"The battle to control public spending is the fight of this decade at all levels of government. If reformers can succeed in a 'progressive' hothouse like Wisconsin, there may be hope."

--

Reach Kenric Ward at kward@sunshinestatenews.com or at (772) 801-5341.



Comments (12)

Jenn
8:05AM DEC 27TH 2011
This does look promiinsg. I'll keep coming back for more.
Annette
4:13PM AUG 16TH 2011
Wisconsin is not a "progressive hothouse."

It is a swing state. We never know which way the wind is blowing here. Right now it is Republican -- we look for a change in the wind direction very soon.
jake
11:24AM AUG 15TH 2011
Hahah the desperation in the authors voice is oozing out!

BYE BYE Republicans. 2012 can't come soon enough. Rick Scott has done nothing but kill jobs, explode the deficit with tax cuts for the rich, and ruin education in Florida for years.
We The People
1:13PM AUG 16TH 2011
BYE BYE Scumocrats! :-) Florida voters spoke loud and clear when they sent the winger known as Alex Stink packing and elected Governor Rick Scott. Even in both houses of the Florida legislature, scumocrats were told to pack their bags by Florida's voters. This is not California. If you want California, MOVE THERE! :-)
John N Florida
3:51PM AUG 16TH 2011
Well, at least we see one person who is willing to admit he voted for the Thief in Chief. Neither Scott nor Rubio managed a 50%+ win.
Scott will be a ONE term Governor. In the meantime, he'll kill as many ALF residents as he can.
wawoo
6:18AM AUG 15TH 2011
Ah, Mr Ward's tone captures the essence of what has come to be the standard of Republican extremism, "close doesn't count in politics."The Repugnicant dictum of win at all costs ande if you win by one govern as if the other side does not exist has cost his state, Florida, and this nation dearly. The Democrats wins in Wisconsin do have significant meaning, government is starting tro go back to the party that does represent the people and understands government needs to work well . There will likely be a recall for Walker, aka Voldemort with hair, as opposed to our dear leader Scot, Voldemort the original edition. The change for the better has started.
Vaughn1111
7:40AM AUG 15TH 2011
There have been 21 successful recalls in our country's entire history. Two of them were last week in Wisconsin. The Wisconsin State senate lost two Republicans and gained two Democrats. These recall elections were in solid Republican districts, one of which has been Republican for over 100 years. This means that not only did the Republicans lose two senators but also a lot of voters as well.
james
2:37AM AUG 17TH 2011
One was in a leaning democrat district and the other was a repub district were the guy was cheating on his wife... Repubs will vote out a scandalous candidate unlike the dems. I guess the revolution is on pause for now. But keep thinking your winning if it makes you feel better. oh.. get a hobby!! I golf, fish, bike and keep busy, so I don't have any time to make up things in my head.
WisResident
12:22PM AUG 16TH 2011
@ Vaughn1111 - You obviously have no idea what you are talking about. One of the two districts has solid Dem roots and it was a miracle they elected a Rep in the first place. The other district is a small rural town that has little to no businesses interested in moving there to create jobs. These residents regardless of party affiliation are dependant on the majority of their job base being sustained by state provided union positions. Any one repeating the dribble you posted has no clue what they are talking about and are only interested in parroting what their preferred sources of information tell them to repeat.
sxsactive
11:10PM AUG 16TH 2011
You are so correct but these people don't want the truth nor will they actually do any research. It's very sad. What I found appalling was the amount of money that unions and democrats contributed to this recall effort. Our court system needs to put teeth back into slander and defamation laws. It's almost unbelievable. They clearly use Alinsky mantra " keep repeating the lie, keep it in the forefront and eventually it will become truth". These thugs are a disgrace to this Country.
American
6:16AM AUG 16TH 2011
but, hey, at least you look on the brite side of the situation...the rocking and the repeating "we got two" makes things better for you... :0P
American
6:13AM AUG 16TH 2011
...the only reason the demonrats that got the seats, won, is because that is what the millions the unions spent got you low lifes...thats all you got for all those millions. Ha Ha Hahahahahah